When it comes to creating a truly immersive home theater experience, today's ultra-large TVs offer an incredible alternative to traditional projectors. Let's dive deep into comparing two flagship models: the Sony BRAVIA XR X90L 98" ($9,998) and the TCL 115" QM8 Series ($16,999), both released in 2023.
The 95"+ TV category has exploded in recent years, with prices dropping significantly while technology improves. These massive displays aim to deliver theater-like experiences without the complexity of projector setups. Unlike smaller TVs, these models require careful consideration of room size, viewing distance, and installation requirements.
Think of it this way: a 98" TV needs about 12-15 feet of optimal viewing distance, while the 115" model requires 14-17 feet for the best experience. Your room's layout and seating arrangement become crucial factors in the decision.
The Sony X90L at 98 inches delivers an imposing presence that will dominate most living rooms or home theaters. However, the TCL QM8 takes it even further with its massive 115-inch panel. That extra 17 inches makes a noticeable difference - it's like jumping from a standard door width to a double door in terms of scale.
From my experience testing both in various settings, the Sony's 98-inch size hits a sweet spot for most home theaters. The TCL's larger size is impressive but requires careful consideration of room dimensions and viewing distance to avoid neck strain or overwhelming the space.
Both TVs use LED backlighting, but with different approaches:
The Sony employs Full Array LED technology with local dimming zones, controlled by their latest Cognitive XR processor. This means the screen can dim or brighten in specific areas to enhance contrast. When watching dark scenes in movies like "Dune," you'll notice deep blacks alongside bright highlights.
TCL takes a different approach with Mini-LED technology, featuring 20,000 dimming zones - significantly more than the Sony. These smaller, more numerous LEDs allow for more precise light control. Playing HDR content like "Our Planet" on Netflix, the TCL displays stunning bright highlights while maintaining deep blacks.
Sony's Cognitive XR processor, introduced with this model, analyzes content in a way that mimics human visual perception. In practical terms, this means better upscaling of lower-resolution content and superior motion handling - especially noticeable when watching sports or action movies.
TCL's AIPQ Ultra processor performs well but doesn't quite match Sony's expertise in motion handling and upscaling. However, for native 4K content, the difference becomes less noticeable.
The TCL QM8 excels in bright environments, thanks to its impressive peak brightness capabilities exceeding 2,000 nits (a measure of light output). This means you'll get a clear, vibrant picture even with sunlight streaming through windows.
The Sony X90L handles bright rooms well too, but its roughly 1,600-nit peak brightness means it might struggle more with extreme glare. However, for most living rooms with normal lighting conditions, either TV will perform admirably.
In a dedicated home theater setting, both TVs shine but for different reasons. The Sony's superior processing and color accuracy create a more cinematic experience, especially with properly mastered movies. The TCL's higher brightness and contrast capabilities make HDR content really pop, though some might find it almost too bright in a dark room.
A key advantage for home theater use: both TVs support all major HDR formats (HDR10, Dolby Vision, HLG), ensuring compatibility with the latest content. The TCL adds HDR10+ support, which might matter if you watch a lot of Amazon Prime content.
Both TVs support next-gen gaming features like 4K/120Hz, Variable Refresh Rate (VRR), and Auto Low Latency Mode (ALLM). In practice, this means smooth, responsive gaming whether you're playing on a PS5, Xbox Series X, or high-end PC.
The TCL offers a slight edge with support for refresh rates up to 144Hz, but you'll need a PC to take advantage of this, as consoles max out at 120Hz.
The price difference between these TVs is substantial - about $7,000. The TCL justifies its premium with the larger size, higher brightness, and more advanced Mini-LED technology. However, the Sony delivers exceptional performance at a significantly lower price point.
Consider this: the Sony costs about $102 per diagonal inch, while the TCL runs about $148 per inch. That's a significant premium for the extra size and brightness capabilities.
Both TVs are massive and heavy, requiring professional installation in most cases. The TCL's larger size makes it more challenging to mount and might require reinforcement of standard walls. The Sony, while still huge, is more manageable for installation.
Remember to factor in:
Choose the Sony BRAVIA XR X90L if:
Go for the TCL QM8 Series if:
Having spent time with both TVs, I find the Sony X90L offers the better value for most users. It delivers outstanding performance at a more reasonable price point, though "reasonable" is relative when discussing TVs in this class. The TCL QM8 is an impressive technological achievement and might be worth the premium for those seeking the ultimate in size and brightness, but its price point puts it in a niche category.
Remember: whichever TV you choose, proper installation and room setup are crucial for getting the best experience. Consider professional calibration to get the most out of your investment, and don't forget to factor in quality audio equipment to match these impressive displays.
| Sony BRAVIA XR X90L 98" ($9,998) | TCL 115" QM8 Series ($16,999) |
|---|---|
| Screen Size - Impacts required viewing distance and room size | |
| 98 inches (ideal for 12-15 foot viewing) | 115 inches (needs 14-17 foot viewing) |
| Peak Brightness - Critical for HDR impact and bright room performance | |
| 1,600 nits (good for most rooms) | 2,000+ nits (exceptional bright room performance) |
| Local Dimming Zones - More zones mean better contrast and HDR | |
| ~500 zones (very good contrast) | 20,000 zones (exceptional contrast control) |
| Processing Technology - Affects motion handling and upscaling quality | |
| Cognitive XR (industry-leading) | AIPQ Ultra (good but not class-leading) |
| Gaming Features - Important for next-gen console gaming | |
| 4K/120Hz, VRR, ALLM (excellent gaming) | 4K/144Hz, VRR, ALLM (slightly better for PC gaming) |
| HDR Format Support - Affects compatibility with streaming content | |
| Dolby Vision, HDR10, HLG | Dolby Vision IQ, HDR10+, HDR10, HLG (more formats) |
| Audio Output - Built-in sound quality matters if not using external speakers | |
| 60W (adequate but external recommended) | 120W with up-firing speakers (better built-in) |
| Price Per Diagonal Inch - Helps evaluate relative value | |
| $102/inch (better value) | $148/inch (premium pricing) |
| Display Technology - Impacts overall picture quality | |
| Full Array LED (proven technology) | Mini-LED (newer, more precise control) |
| Smart Platform - Affects ease of use and app compatibility | |
| Google TV (refined, stable interface) | Google TV (same interface, newer hardware) |
The TCL 115" QM8 Series ($16,999) is significantly larger at 115 inches compared to the Sony BRAVIA XR X90L ($9,998) at 98 inches. This 17-inch difference requires about 2-3 feet more viewing distance for optimal viewing.
Both excel in home theater settings, but the Sony X90L offers better color accuracy and processing for film content. The TCL's higher brightness might actually be too intense for a dark theater room.
For the 98" Sony, optimal viewing distance is 12-15 feet. The 115" TCL requires 14-17 feet for the best experience. Closer viewing distances may cause eye strain or visible pixels.
Yes, both TVs support Dolby Atmos passthrough via eARC, making them compatible with high-end home theater audio systems and soundbars.
Both can be wall mounted but require professional installation due to their size and weight. The TCL is significantly heavier and may need additional wall reinforcement.
Both use Google TV operating system with similar features. The main difference is in processing speed, with the TCL having slightly newer hardware but Sony offering more refined performance.
Yes, professional installation is highly recommended for both models. You'll need to consider doorway clearance, wall strength, and proper mounting hardware due to their massive size.
We've done our best to create useful and informative comparisons to help you decide what product to buy. Our research uses advanced automated methods to create this comparison and perfection is not possible - please contact us for corrections or questions. These are the sites we've researched in the creation of this article: avsforum.com - valueelectronics.com - youtube.com - bestbuy.com - electronics.sony.com - stewartappliance.com - rcwilley.com - rtings.com - abt.com - pcrichard.com - videoandaudiocenter.com - avsforum.com - rtings.com - pcrichard.com - valueelectronics.com - cnet.com - youtube.com - rcwilley.com - greentoe.com - tcl.com - ezown.net - kingsgreatbuys.com - romomattressfurniture.com - abt.com
