Choosing Between Premium Atmos Soundbars: A Detailed Comparison

The search for better TV audio has led many to consider premium soundbars, with Sonos Arc ($800) and TCL Q85H Q Class ($999) representing two distinct approaches to home theater sound. Let's explore how these systems tackle the challenge of delivering immersive audio in modern homes.

Understanding the Category

Today's premium soundbars aim to bridge the gap between basic TV speakers and complex home theater setups. Both systems support Dolby Atmos, which adds height channels to create a three-dimensional sound field. Think of it as audio that can place sounds precisely in space – like a helicopter flying overhead or rain falling from above.

Core Differences That Matter

The Sonos Arc takes a minimalist approach, starting with a single sophisticated bar that handles all audio channels. Released in 2020, it represents Sonos' flagship soundbar, engineered to deliver room-filling sound from one unit. The bar houses 11 drivers, including up-firing speakers for Atmos effects.

In contrast, the newer TCL Q85H (2024) provides a complete surround system out of the box. You get the main bar, a wireless subwoofer, and two wireless surround speakers – each with their own up-firing drivers for height effects. This creates a true 7.1.4 setup, meaning seven surround channels, one subwoofer channel, and four height channels.

Audio Performance Deep-Dive

Movie and TV Performance

The Sonos Arc excels at clarity and precision. Its speech enhancement feature makes dialogue exceptionally clear, while careful tuning ensures sound effects remain balanced rather than overwhelming. The single-bar approach means less dramatic surround effects, but the quality of sound is consistently high.

TCL's Q85H delivers more immediate impact. With dedicated surrounds and a subwoofer, explosions have more punch, and effects truly wrap around you. However, some users report less refined sound quality – think more "exciting" but potentially less accurate.

Music Playback

Here's where the Sonos heritage shines through. The Arc produces detailed, well-balanced music with excellent stereo separation. Bass is controlled and natural, though not as deep as systems with dedicated subwoofers.

The Q85H's stronger bass and wider soundstage can make music more engaging for some genres, particularly electronic or rock. However, it may require more tweaking of settings to achieve balanced sound for acoustic or classical music.

Technical Capabilities

Both support modern audio formats including Dolby Atmos and DTS:X. The Sonos Arc processes these through 11 Class-D amplifiers, each precisely tuned to its driver. The TCL uses 15 total speakers across its system, potentially creating more precise spatial audio placement.

System Flexibility and Future-Proofing

The Sonos ecosystem represents a significant advantage for the Arc. Users can start with the bar alone and add the Sonos Sub and surround speakers later. The system also integrates seamlessly with other Sonos speakers for whole-home audio.

TCL's approach provides everything upfront but lacks expansion options. While this means instant gratification, it may limit future upgrades. The included wireless surrounds are specifically designed for this system and can't be upgraded individually.

Smart Features and Connectivity

The Sonos Arc offers sophisticated smart features including voice assistant support (Alexa and Google Assistant), AirPlay 2, and the robust Sonos app. The app provides detailed EQ settings and the unique Trueplay tuning system, which uses an iOS device's microphone to optimize sound for your room's acoustics.

The TCL Q85H includes basic smart features through its app and supports Bluetooth streaming. Its AI Sonic room calibration system helps optimize sound but doesn't offer the same level of fine-tuning as Trueplay.

Room Considerations and Installation

Room size and layout significantly impact the decision between these systems. The Sonos Arc works well in small to medium rooms where a single bar can effectively project sound. Its clean design and single-unit approach minimize visual impact.

The TCL Q85H requires more space and planning for optimal speaker placement. The wireless surrounds need power outlets and appropriate positioning behind the listening area. However, this setup provides more authentic surround sound when space permits.

Value Proposition

At $800, the Sonos Arc represents a premium investment that can grow over time. Adding a Sonos Sub ($749) and surrounds ($458 for One SL pair) brings the total to around $2,000 for a complete system.

The TCL Q85H's $999 MSRP (often available for $599) includes everything needed for full surround sound, representing significant value for those wanting immediate immersion.

How to Make Your Decision

Consider these key factors when choosing between the Sonos Arc and TCL Q85H:

1. Space and Setup
   • Limited space? The Arc's single-bar solution might be ideal
   • Room for surrounds? The Q85H provides immediate full surround
2. Budget and Timing
   • Want to start small and expand? Consider the Arc
   • Need complete surround now at a lower total cost? The Q85H wins
3. Primary Use
   • Focus on music and streaming? The Arc's refined sound and ecosystem shine
   • Mainly movies and gaming? The Q85H's immediate full surround might be preferable
4. Future Plans
   • Planning whole-home audio? The Sonos ecosystem offers more possibilities
   • Just need great TV sound? The TCL's complete package delivers

Both systems represent valid approaches to modern home theater audio, but they serve different needs. The Sonos Arc excels in sound quality, ecosystem integration, and expandability, while the TCL Q85H offers immediate full surround sound at a compelling price point. Your specific room, budget, and priorities will determine which approach makes more sense for your situation.

Sonos Arc Wireless Sound Bar with Dolby Atmos, Apple AirPlay 2, and Built-in Voice Assistant (White) Deals and Prices

TCL Q85H Q Class 7.1.4 Channel Sound Bar System Deals and Prices