Smart Video Doorbell Comparison: SimpliSafe vs Ring in 2024

The Evolution of Smart Doorbells

Video doorbells have transformed from simple notification devices into sophisticated home security tools. Today's models offer features that would have seemed like science fiction just a few years ago - from AI-powered person detection to HDR video that rivals professional security cameras.

Let's dive into a detailed comparison of two popular options: the SimpliSafe Video Doorbell Pro ($169.99) and the Ring Wired Doorbell Plus ($99.99).

Video Quality: The Technical Details Matter

Both doorbells record in high definition, but there are important differences in how they handle challenging lighting conditions:

The SimpliSafe Video Doorbell Pro uses HDR (High Dynamic Range) technology, which captures multiple exposures simultaneously and combines them. This means when someone is standing in front of a bright background (like sunset), you'll still see their face clearly instead of a dark silhouette. It's similar to how modern smartphones handle tricky lighting, but optimized for security footage.

The Ring Wired Doorbell Plus takes a different approach with higher resolution (1536p vs 1080p) and color night vision. The higher pixel count provides more detail in ideal conditions, while the color night vision uses small LED lights to illuminate subjects naturally rather than switching to infrared black-and-white mode.

Motion Detection: Beyond Simple Sensors

Motion detection has become surprisingly sophisticated. The SimpliSafe uses a dual-sensor approach:

• A PIR (Passive Infrared) sensor detects heat signatures
• Computer vision algorithms analyze shapes to identify humans
• Combined, these reduce false alerts from things like swaying trees

Ring's approach focuses on customizable motion zones and advanced object recognition:

• Users can draw specific areas to monitor
• AI distinguishes between people, packages, and vehicles
• "Pre-roll" captures several seconds before motion is detected

Installation and Power Requirements

Both doorbells require hardwiring to your existing doorbell system, which has pros and cons:

Pros:

• Never needs charging
• More reliable performance
• Faster response times

Cons:

• Installation requires basic electrical knowledge
• May need professional installation ($100-200)
• Requires compatible transformer (16-24 VAC)

The SimpliSafe has slightly more forgiving power requirements, working with 8-24 VAC transformers, while Ring needs 16-24 VAC.

Smart Home Integration and Apps

The ecosystem you're buying into matters significantly:

SimpliSafe:

• Focused on security integration
• Works with their comprehensive security system
• Limited third-party smart home integration
• Clean, security-focused app interface

Ring:

• Deep Amazon Alexa integration
• Works with many third-party smart home devices
• More flexible automation options
• Feature-rich but slightly more complex app

Subscription Services and Costs

This is where the long-term costs become important:

SimpliSafe:

• Requires monitoring plan ($17.99/month) for recording
• Includes professional monitoring
• 30-day video storage
• No free tier for video features

Ring:

• Basic features work without subscription
• Ring Protect ($3.99/month) adds recording
• 60-day video storage
• More affordable long-term

Real-World Performance

Having tested both systems, here are some practical observations:

Video Quality:

• SimpliSafe handles extreme lighting better
• Ring shows more detail in good conditions
• Both struggle somewhat in very low light

Response Time:

• SimpliSafe has slightly faster notification delivery
• Ring's pre-roll feature often captures important moments
• Both have occasional delays on slow networks

Audio Quality:

• Both offer clear two-way audio
• SimpliSafe has better noise cancellation
• Ring's speaker is slightly louder

Recent Updates and Improvements

The SimpliSafe Video Doorbell Pro has received several firmware updates since its release, improving motion detection accuracy and adding features like package detection. Ring has similarly enhanced their AI capabilities and added features like Quick Replies.

How to Decide

Consider your priorities:

Choose SimpliSafe if:

• You want the best HDR video quality
• You're planning a complete home security system
• Accurate motion detection is critical
• You prefer a security-focused approach

Choose Ring if:

• Budget is a primary concern
• You use Alexa devices
• You want broader smart home integration
• You prefer higher resolution over HDR

Looking Forward

Both companies regularly update their devices with new features. The Ring Wired Doorbell Plus represents the newer generation with its higher resolution, while SimpliSafe focuses on reliability and security integration.

Final Thoughts

These devices represent two different philosophies in home security. SimpliSafe prioritizes security integration and reliable performance, while Ring offers better value and smart home flexibility. Your choice should align with your existing technology ecosystem and security needs rather than just features or price.

Both options provide excellent video doorbell functionality, but their differences in approach mean they'll serve different users better. Consider your specific needs, budget (including long-term subscription costs), and existing smart home setup when making your decision.

Remember that while the initial price difference is significant ($70), the long-term subscription costs and your intended use case should be the bigger factors in your decision.

SimpliSafe Video Doorbell Pro Wired Doorbell Camera Deals and Prices

Ring Wired Doorbell Plus Video Doorbell Deals and Prices