The smart doorbell market has evolved significantly in recent years, transforming from simple video intercoms to sophisticated security devices. Let's dive into a detailed comparison of two popular options: the SimpliSafe Video Doorbell Pro and the newer Ring Battery Doorbell.
Smart doorbells have become increasingly sophisticated since their introduction around 2013. The technology has progressed from basic video feeds to incorporating AI-powered person detection, package monitoring, and integration with broader smart home ecosystems. Both SimpliSafe and Ring have been at the forefront of this evolution, though they've taken different approaches to solving home security challenges.
The SimpliSafe Video Doorbell Pro requires existing doorbell wiring (8-24 VAC), which might seem limiting but offers distinct advantages. Once installed, you'll never worry about charging batteries or power interruptions. The installation process typically takes about 15-20 minutes if you're replacing an existing doorbell, though you might want to call an electrician if you're starting from scratch.
The Ring Battery Doorbell takes a more flexible approach with its rechargeable battery system. This design choice makes it ideal for renters or homes without existing doorbell wiring. The battery typically lasts 3-6 months, depending on usage patterns and environmental factors. Ring's quick-release mount system makes battery changes surprisingly convenient - you can swap batteries in under a minute.
SimpliSafe's implementation of HDR (High Dynamic Range) video makes a noticeable difference in challenging lighting conditions. When someone stands at your door on a bright day, HDR helps balance the shadows and highlights, ensuring you can see both their face and any packages they might be carrying.
Ring's standard HD video is still quite good, but the lack of HDR can sometimes result in blown-out highlights or dark shadows in extreme lighting conditions. However, Ring compensates with excellent night vision capabilities, offering color night vision in moderately lit conditions.
The SimpliSafe's 162° field of view versus Ring's 150° x 150° might seem like a minor difference, but it can affect what you'll see in practice:
Both doorbells offer motion detection, but their approaches differ:
SimpliSafe uses a dual-sensor system:
Ring's system focuses on:
The SimpliSafe Video Doorbell Pro requires a monitoring plan ($17.99/month) for video recording and advanced features. Ring's basic features work without a subscription, though cloud storage requires Ring Protect ($3.99/month).
In daily use, both doorbells perform their core functions well, but there are notable differences:
SimpliSafe strengths:
Ring advantages:
Both doorbells are designed to handle various weather conditions, though the SimpliSafe has a slight edge in extreme temperatures due to its hardwired design. The Ring's battery performance can be affected by very cold weather, potentially requiring more frequent charging.
The Ring Battery Doorbell shines in its integration capabilities:
SimpliSafe's approach is more closed:
Remember to factor in:
Both companies regularly update their firmware to add features and improve performance. Ring has been particularly aggressive with updates, adding features like package detection and enhanced motion zones post-launch. SimpliSafe tends to focus on security and reliability improvements rather than new features.
The smart doorbell market continues to evolve, with both companies likely to introduce new features through software updates. Ring's approach typically makes new features available to existing customers, while SimpliSafe's updates focus on performance and security improvements.
For most users, the Ring Battery Doorbell offers the best balance of features, flexibility, and value. However, if you're already invested in the SimpliSafe ecosystem or prioritize video quality above all else, the SimpliSafe Video Doorbell Pro remains an excellent choice.
Remember, the best choice depends on your specific needs, existing smart home setup, and whether you prefer the convenience of battery power or the reliability of a wired connection.
| SimpliSafe Video Doorbell Pro | Ring Battery Doorbell |
|---|---|
| Video Quality - Affects how clearly you can identify visitors and read packages | |
| 1080p HDR with improved contrast | 1536p HD without HDR |
| Field of View - Determines how much of your porch area you can see | |
| 162° horizontal view | 150° horizontal x 150° vertical view |
| Power Source - Impacts installation flexibility and maintenance | |
| Hardwired (8-24 VAC required) | Rechargeable battery (3-6 months per charge) |
| Motion Detection - Affects accuracy of alerts and false alarm frequency | |
| Dual sensors (PIR + image analysis) | Single sensor with customizable zones |
| Night Vision - Critical for after-dark monitoring | |
| Infrared night vision | Color night vision in moderate lighting |
| Smart Home Integration - Important for ecosystem compatibility | |
| Limited to SimpliSafe ecosystem | Works with Alexa and Ring ecosystem |
| Weather Resistance - Affects reliability in extreme conditions | |
| -4°F to 122°F operating range | -5°F to 122°F operating range |
| Subscription Requirements - Impacts total cost of ownership | |
| Requires plan ($17.99/mo) for recording | Basic features work without subscription |
| Initial Cost - Upfront investment | |
| $169 | $99 |
| Installation - Consider skill level and existing setup | |
| Professional installation recommended | DIY-friendly, no wiring needed |
| Package Detection - Important for delivery monitoring | |
| Basic motion detection only | Dedicated package alerts with subscription |
| Two-Way Audio - For visitor communication | |
| HD audio with noise cancellation | Standard two-way audio |
For most users, the Ring Battery Doorbell offers better value at $99 compared to the $169 SimpliSafe Video Doorbell Pro. Ring provides more flexible installation and lower subscription costs, though SimpliSafe offers superior HDR video quality.
The SimpliSafe Video Doorbell Pro requires existing doorbell wiring (8-24 VAC), while the Ring Battery Doorbell can be installed anywhere using its battery power, making it more versatile for different mounting locations.
The SimpliSafe Video Doorbell Pro offers 1080p HDR video which provides better contrast and clarity in challenging lighting conditions. The Ring Battery Doorbell features 1536p resolution but lacks HDR, making it slightly less capable in extreme lighting situations.
Both can display video feeds on TVs through their respective ecosystems. The Ring Battery Doorbell works better with home theater setups due to its Alexa integration, allowing viewing on Fire TV devices. SimpliSafe has more limited display options.
The Ring Battery Doorbell offers color night vision in moderately lit conditions, while the SimpliSafe Video Doorbell Pro uses traditional infrared night vision. Ring's color capability can provide more detail in well-lit porches.
Ring's basic features work without a subscription, with cloud storage available for $3.99/month. SimpliSafe requires a $17.99/month monitoring plan for recording features. The Ring Battery Doorbell is more cost-effective long-term.
The SimpliSafe Video Doorbell Pro uses dual sensors (PIR and image analysis) for more accurate detection. The Ring Battery Doorbell offers customizable motion zones but may generate more false alerts.
The Ring Battery Doorbell typically lasts 3-6 months per charge, depending on usage and weather conditions. The SimpliSafe Video Doorbell Pro doesn't require charging as it's hardwired.
Both doorbells support multiple viewers through their apps. The Ring Battery Doorbell offers more viewing options through Alexa devices, while SimpliSafe is limited to mobile devices and their web interface.
The Ring Battery Doorbell includes dedicated package detection alerts with a subscription. The SimpliSafe Video Doorbell Pro relies on general motion detection for package monitoring.
Both doorbells are designed for outdoor use and have similar operating temperature ranges (-4°F to 122°F). The SimpliSafe Video Doorbell Pro may be slightly more reliable in extreme conditions due to its hardwired power.
Both work well as part of larger security systems. The SimpliSafe Video Doorbell Pro integrates better with professional monitoring services, while the Ring Battery Doorbell offers better smart home integration and DIY security options.
We've done our best to create useful and informative comparisons to help you decide what product to buy. Our research uses advanced automated methods to create this comparison and perfection is not possible - please contact us for corrections or questions. These are the sites we've researched in the creation of this article: trustedreviews.com - jeffgeerling.com - security.org - support.simplisafe.com - security.org - simplisafe.co.uk - consumerreports.org - bestbuy.com - support.simplisafe.com - simplisafe.com - simplisafe.com - safehome.org - pcrichard.com - marketplace.ladwp.com - ae-en.ring.com - batteries4pro.com - de-de.ring.com - de-de.ring.com - careyscommunications.com
