Today's video doorbells have transformed from simple chime boxes into sophisticated security devices. Let's compare two popular options: the SimpliSafe Video Doorbell Pro ($169.99) and the Google Nest Hello ($229.99), examining how they stack up in 2024.
The Nest Hello debuted in 2018, bringing Google's AI expertise to our doorsteps. SimpliSafe followed later that year with their Pro model, targeting integration with their popular security system. Both have received numerous software updates since launch, though the hardware remains unchanged.
When it comes to seeing who's at your door, resolution tells only part of the story. The Nest Hello captures video at 1600x1200 with HDR (High Dynamic Range), which helps balance bright sunshine against shadowy porches. The SimpliSafe Pro offers 1080p resolution, also with HDR, though its implementation isn't quite as refined.
What's really interesting is how they handle challenging lighting. The Nest Hello's HDR processing shows more detail in shadows while preventing bright areas from washing out. SimpliSafe's solution is good, but you'll notice more blown-out highlights on sunny days.
Both doorbells offer similar viewing angles - SimpliSafe at 162° and Nest at 160°. This might seem like a minor difference, but the way they use these angles varies:
Here's where things get technically interesting. The SimpliSafe Pro uses a dual-sensor approach:
The Nest Hello takes a different route, using advanced AI to recognize:
This AI-powered approach means fewer false alerts from swaying trees or passing cars. Both systems work well, but Nest's solution is more sophisticated and customizable.
Both doorbells require hardwiring, but they have different needs:
SimpliSafe Pro:
Nest Hello:
The Nest Hello shines in smart home integration, working seamlessly with:
The SimpliSafe Pro focuses primarily on its own ecosystem:
Here's where ongoing costs come into play:
SimpliSafe:
Nest Hello:
Having tested both systems extensively, here's what stands out:
The Nest Hello typically alerts you about 1-2 seconds faster when someone approaches. This might seem minor, but it gives you more time to respond to visitors or delivery people.
Both use infrared LEDs for night vision, but Nest's implementation provides clearer images and better contrast in complete darkness.
Two-way audio is clearer on the Nest Hello, with better noise cancellation and less lag. SimpliSafe's audio is perfectly functional but can sound slightly compressed.
Both systems are generally reliable, but:
The SimpliSafe Pro offers excellent value at $169.99, especially if you're already invested in SimpliSafe security. The Nest Hello justifies its higher $229.99 price through superior AI features and video quality, but requires a stronger commitment to the Google ecosystem.
Choose SimpliSafe Pro if you:
Choose Nest Hello if you:
Both doorbells represent solid choices in 2024, but they serve different users. The SimpliSafe Pro offers great value and simplicity, while the Nest Hello provides more advanced features and better integration. Consider your existing smart home setup, budget, and desired features when making your choice.
Remember that both products continue to improve through software updates, making them better values over time. Whether you choose the pragmatic SimpliSafe approach or Nest's more ambitious offering, you'll get a capable guardian for your front door.
| SimpliSafe Video Doorbell Pro | Google Nest Hello |
|---|---|
| Resolution & HDR - Determines image clarity and handling of bright/dark areas | |
| 1080p HD with HDR | 1600x1200 (2K) with HDR, better dynamic range handling |
| Field of View - Affects how much of your porch/entryway you can see | |
| 162° diagonal, wider horizontal view | 160° diagonal, taller aspect ratio for packages |
| Motion Detection - Impacts accuracy of alerts and false alarm reduction | |
| Dual sensors: heat signature + visual detection | AI-powered with person, package, vehicle recognition |
| Power Requirements - Determines compatibility with existing doorbell | |
| 8-24V AC, more flexible for older systems | 16-24V AC, stricter requirements |
| Night Vision - Critical for after-dark security | |
| IR LED-based, good clarity | IR LED-based with superior contrast and detail |
| Storage Options - Affects ongoing costs and footage access | |
| Cloud only, requires $5/month minimum | Free 3-hour history, Nest Aware from $6/month |
| Smart Home Integration - Important for automation and convenience | |
| Limited to SimpliSafe ecosystem | Extensive Google Home and third-party support |
| Weather Resistance - Ensures year-round reliability | |
| Weather-resistant, -4°F to 122°F | Weather-resistant, -13°F to 113°F |
| Two-Way Audio - Key for visitor interaction | |
| Basic two-way audio with some compression | HD audio with noise cancellation |
| Price - Initial investment | |
| $169.99, better value if in SimpliSafe ecosystem | $229.99, premium features justify cost |
The Google Nest Hello offers superior video quality and AI features, while the SimpliSafe Video Doorbell Pro provides better value at $169.99 vs $229.99. Nest Hello is better for smart home integration, while SimpliSafe works best within its own security ecosystem.
Yes, both can display video feeds on smart TVs and home theater displays. The Nest Hello has better integration with Google/Android TV systems, while the SimpliSafe Pro requires viewing through its app.
The Google Nest Hello offers superior night vision with better contrast and clarity in complete darkness. The SimpliSafe Pro provides adequate night vision but with less detail and more noise in the image.
Yes, both require subscriptions for full features. SimpliSafe starts at $5/month, while Nest Aware begins at $6/month. The Nest Hello offers more free features than the SimpliSafe Pro.
The SimpliSafe Video Doorbell Pro has more flexible power requirements (8-24V AC) and simpler installation. The Nest Hello needs 16-24V AC and requires a chime connector installation.
The Nest Hello works seamlessly with Google Home and has limited Alexa support. The SimpliSafe Pro has basic smart home integration but works best within its own ecosystem.
The Nest Hello features advanced AI-powered detection for people, packages, and vehicles. The SimpliSafe Pro uses dual sensors (heat and visual) but isn't as sophisticated in object recognition.
The Nest Hello offers 1600x1200 (2K) resolution with superior HDR processing. The SimpliSafe Pro provides 1080p HD with HDR, but doesn't handle extreme lighting conditions as well.
Both doorbells support multiple devices. The Nest Hello offers better multi-device support and smart display integration, while the SimpliSafe Pro is more limited but still functional.
Both are weather-resistant, but the SimpliSafe Pro has a slightly wider operating temperature range (-4°F to 122°F) compared to the Nest Hello (-13°F to 113°F).
Yes, both work with existing chimes. The SimpliSafe Pro is more compatible with older systems, while the Nest Hello requires specific voltage requirements and a chime connector.
The Nest Hello provides clearer HD audio with noise cancellation. The SimpliSafe Pro offers standard two-way audio that's functional but may have some compression artifacts.
We've done our best to create useful and informative comparisons to help you decide what product to buy. Our research uses advanced automated methods to create this comparison and perfection is not possible - please contact us for corrections or questions. These are the sites we've researched in the creation of this article: trustedreviews.com - jeffgeerling.com - security.org - support.simplisafe.com - security.org - simplisafe.co.uk - consumerreports.org - bestbuy.com - support.simplisafe.com - simplisafe.com - simplisafe.com - safehome.org - tomsguide.com - youtube.com - techradar.com - cnet.com - safewise.com - support.google.com - drivenbydecor.com - youtube.com - safehome.org - cdn.hibuwebsites.com - beachcamera.com - security.org - youtube.com - acerenttoown.com
