Smart Video Doorbell Battle: SimpliSafe vs Arlo - A Complete Comparison

The Evolution of Smart Doorbells

Smart video doorbells have transformed from simple notification devices into sophisticated security hubs. When the SimpliSafe Video Doorbell Pro launched in 2018 at $169, it brought professional-grade security features to home users. The newer Arlo Video Doorbell 2nd Generation at $79.99, released in late 2021, represents the latest evolution in consumer doorbell technology.

Understanding the Technology

Before diving into specifics, let's understand what makes these devices "smart." Both doorbells use HD cameras with High Dynamic Range (HDR) - think of HDR as your camera automatically adjusting to show details in both bright and dark areas simultaneously. They connect to your home's Wi-Fi network, sending real-time video and notifications to your smartphone.

Installation Reality Check

Both the SimpliSafe and Arlo doorbells require hardwiring to your existing doorbell system. This means you'll need:

• 8-24V AC power supply (standard doorbell transformer)
• Stable Wi-Fi connection
• Smartphone for setup and monitoring

The installation process typically takes 20-30 minutes if you're replacing an existing doorbell. Neither offers battery backup, which means during power outages, you're without doorbell service.

Video Performance Deep Dive

Here's where things get interesting. The Arlo boasts 2K resolution (1536x1536 pixels) with a 180° viewing angle - that's practically a fish-eye view of your entire porch. The SimpliSafe offers 1080p HD with a 162° view.

In real-world use, this means:

• Arlo provides clearer license plate reading at distance
• SimpliSafe offers better low-light performance
• Both handle bright sunlight well thanks to HDR
• Arlo's wider angle catches more package deliveries

Night Vision Capabilities

Both systems use infrared LEDs for night vision, but they approach it differently:

• SimpliSafe uses dual-sensor technology (heat + visual)
• Arlo relies more heavily on software enhancement
• Both produce clear black-and-white footage at night

Smart Detection Features

The SimpliSafe Video Doorbell Pro employs a sophisticated dual-sensor system that's particularly impressive. It combines:

1. Heat signature detection
2. Visual pattern recognition
3. AI-powered human form detection

This results in fewer false alarms from passing cars or swaying trees. The Arlo takes a different approach, using primarily software-based detection with a single sensor. While effective, it requires a subscription to maintain advanced detection features after the initial three-month trial.

Smart Home Integration

Here's where your existing tech setup matters:

SimpliSafe Ecosystem:

• Works with Alexa and Google Assistant
• Integrates with SimpliSafe security system
• Supports IFTTT for custom automations

Arlo Environment:

• Alexa compatibility only
• Works with other Arlo cameras
• Limited third-party integration

Subscription Services Compared

Monthly costs affect total ownership value:

SimpliSafe Plans:

• Basic: $5/month (30-day video storage)
• Standard: $10/month (10 cameras, advanced features)
• No subscription: Basic functionality maintained

Arlo Plans:

• Essential: $3/month per camera
• Premier: $10/month (up to 5 cameras)
• Required for person detection after trial

Weather Resistance and Durability

Both doorbells are built for outdoor use, but there are differences:

• SimpliSafe: Rated for -4°F to 122°F
• Arlo: Rated for -4°F to 113°F
• Both handle rain and snow effectively

Technical Improvements Since Launch

The SimpliSafe has received multiple firmware updates since 2018:

• Enhanced motion detection algorithms
• Improved night vision performance
• Better Wi-Fi stability

The Arlo brought several improvements over its predecessor:

• Higher resolution sensor
• Wider viewing angle
• More efficient processor
• Better power management

Real-World Performance Analysis

Daily use reveals important distinctions:

Motion Detection Accuracy

• SimpliSafe excels at reducing false alerts
• Arlo offers more customizable detection zones
• Both handle package detection well

Video Quality

• Arlo's 2K resolution shows more detail
• SimpliSafe's HDR handles contrast better
• Both provide good enough quality for security purposes

Audio Quality

• Two-way audio is clear on both devices
• SimpliSafe has less latency
• Arlo offers pre-recorded responses

Making the Decision

Choose the SimpliSafe Video Doorbell Pro if:

• You want the most reliable motion detection
• You're building a complete security system
• You value lower long-term subscription costs
• You need Google Assistant integration

Choose the Arlo Video Doorbell 2nd Generation if:

• Highest video resolution is priority
• You need the widest viewing angle
• You're okay with subscription-based features
• You want pre-recorded response options

Value Assessment

The SimpliSafe's higher initial cost $169 versus Arlo's $79.99 needs context. Consider:

• Required subscription costs
• Feature accessibility without subscription
• Integration with existing systems
• Long-term reliability

Final Thoughts

Both doorbells represent different approaches to home security. The SimpliSafe focuses on integration and reliable security features, while the Arlo pushes video quality and viewing angle advantages. Your choice should align with your specific needs and existing smart home setup.

The technology in both devices continues to improve through software updates, making either a solid investment for home security. Remember that the best doorbell camera is the one that fits your specific needs and budget while providing the features you'll actually use.

SimpliSafe Video Doorbell Pro Wired Doorbell Camera Deals and Prices

Arlo Video Doorbell 2nd Generation Deals and Prices