Choosing Between Today's Top Video Doorbells: SimpliSafe Pro vs Arlo Essential

In recent years, video doorbells have transformed from novelty gadgets into essential home security devices. Let's compare two popular options: the $169.99 SimpliSafe Video Doorbell Pro and the $59.99 Arlo Essential Wired Video Doorbell, helping you decide which best fits your needs.

The Evolution of Video Doorbells

Video doorbells have come a long way since SimpliSafe released their Pro model in 2018. When the SimpliSafe Pro first launched, its HDR video was groundbreaking for doorbell cameras. Meanwhile, the newer Arlo Essential represents the latest generation of more affordable yet feature-rich options.

Think of these devices as your front door's security guard and receptionist rolled into one. They notify you when someone approaches, let you speak with visitors remotely, and record important events. But each takes a slightly different approach to these tasks.

Video Quality: The Details Matter

Both doorbells deliver clear video, but there are important differences in how they capture footage:

The SimpliSafe Pro uses 1080p resolution with HDR (High Dynamic Range) imaging. HDR is particularly valuable for doorbell cameras because it helps balance bright backlighting (like afternoon sun) with shadowed areas (like your covered porch). This means you'll see faces clearly even in challenging lighting conditions.

The Arlo Essential takes a different approach with its 1536x1536 square resolution and 180-degree field of view. The square format actually makes sense for a doorbell, showing more vertical space for packages on your doorstep and full-height views of visitors.

In real-world use, both cameras produce clear, useful footage. SimpliSafe's HDR advantage is most noticeable during sunset hours or on bright days, while Arlo's wider view might catch more activity at the edges of your porch.

Smart Features and Detection Capabilities

Motion Detection

The SimpliSafe Pro employs an impressive dual-sensor system that combines heat detection with image recognition. This means it can tell the difference between a person walking up and a car driving by, reducing false alerts. Over time, the system has gotten better through software updates, learning to distinguish between more types of motion.

The Arlo Essential uses more traditional motion detection but compensates with advanced software features like package detection and customizable activity zones. You can tell it to ignore movement in certain areas, like a busy sidewalk, while staying alert to your doorstep.

Smart Home Integration

This is where the two systems really diverge. SimpliSafe works best as part of their broader security ecosystem, automatically recording when other SimpliSafe sensors detect activity. It supports basic Alexa and Google Assistant integration but remains somewhat limited outside its own ecosystem.

Arlo takes a more open approach, working well with Amazon Alexa, Google Assistant, and Apple HomeKit. This flexibility means you can view your doorbell camera on more devices and integrate it with more smart home routines.

Installation and Power Requirements

Both doorbells require hardwiring, which might seem daunting but actually provides more reliable operation than battery-powered alternatives. The SimpliSafe Pro needs 8-24V AC power, while the Arlo Essential requires 16-24V AC. If you're replacing an existing doorbell, either should work with your current wiring, but it's worth checking your transformer's voltage first.

Installation takes about 30 minutes for either model if you're comfortable with basic electrical work. Both companies provide clear instructions and helpful support videos.

Subscription Services and Costs

Here's where the long-term costs come into play. The SimpliSafe Pro starts at $169.99 but requires a $5/month subscription for video recording. Without it, you can only view live video and receive alerts.

The Arlo Essential costs less upfront at $59.99 but needs an Arlo Secure plan for advanced features like person detection and cloud storage. These plans start at $3/month for a single camera.

Performance in Real-World Conditions

Both cameras handle weather well, operating in temperatures from -20°F to 120°F. SimpliSafe's HDR advantage becomes apparent in challenging lighting conditions, while Arlo's wider field of view captures more activity around your door.

Night vision performance is comparable between the two, with both using infrared LEDs to illuminate visitors without disturbing them. The SimpliSafe's dual-sensor system maintains its advantage at night, more accurately distinguishing between people and other moving objects.

How to Decide

Choose the SimpliSafe Video Doorbell Pro if:

• You already use or plan to get SimpliSafe security
• Your entryway has challenging lighting conditions
• You value advanced motion detection accuracy
• Budget isn't your primary concern

Choose the Arlo Essential Wired Video Doorbell if:

• You want the widest possible view
• Price is a major factor
• You need flexible smart home integration
• You want built-in deterrence features like the siren

Final Thoughts

These doorbells represent two different approaches to home security. The SimpliSafe Pro excels as part of a comprehensive security system, while the Arlo Essential offers excellent standalone value with broader compatibility.

For most users, the Arlo's lower price and wider compatibility make it the better choice. However, if you're building a complete home security system or need the best possible image quality in challenging conditions, SimpliSafe's premium features justify its higher price.

Remember, the best video doorbell is the one that fits your specific needs and integrates well with your existing smart home setup. Both these options have proven reliable over time, with regular software updates adding features and improving performance since their release.

SimpliSafe Video Doorbell Pro Wired Doorbell Camera Deals and Prices

Arlo Essential Wired Video Doorbell Deals and Prices