Choosing Between Premium Ultra Short Throw Projectors: A Detailed Comparison

The home theater projector market has evolved dramatically in recent years, with Ultra Short Throw (UST) projectors emerging as an elegant solution for those seeking massive screens without traditional ceiling mounting. Today, we'll compare two leading options: the Samsung Premiere 9 ($5,999) and the Epson EpiqVision Ultra LS800 ($2,999).

The Evolution of UST Projectors

UST technology has matured significantly since its introduction. These projectors sit just inches from your wall, using sophisticated optics to create huge images without the typical long throw distance required by traditional projectors. Both of our contenders represent the latest generation of this technology, with the Samsung launching in late 2022 and the Epson following in early 2023.

Light Engine Technology: A Tale of Two Approaches

The most fundamental difference between these projectors lies in their light sources. The Samsung Premiere 9 employs a triple laser system, using separate red, green, and blue lasers to create light. This approach allows for incredibly precise color control and an expansive color gamut - think of it like having a professional artist's full palette of colors to work with, rather than just the basic set.

In contrast, the Epson LS800 uses a blue laser combined with a phosphor wheel and 3LCD technology. While this might sound less advanced, it actually offers some distinct advantages. The 3LCD system splits light into three separate colors simultaneously, eliminating the "rainbow effect" that some viewers notice with single-chip DLP projectors like the Samsung. It's also more efficient at producing brightness, which explains the Epson's impressive 4,000 lumens output.

Real-World Performance

Brightness and Ambient Light Handling

The Epson's higher brightness rating isn't just a number - it makes a real difference in everyday use. In my testing, the LS800 maintained vibrant, watchable images even with significant ambient light. This makes it particularly well-suited for multipurpose rooms where complete light control isn't possible.

The Samsung, while still bright at 3,450 lumens, performs best in more controlled lighting conditions. However, its superior contrast and black levels become apparent in darker rooms, where it delivers a more cinema-like experience.

Color Performance and Image Quality

Here's where the Samsung's premium positioning becomes clear. Its triple laser system can reproduce 106% of the BT.2020 color space - the current gold standard for digital video. This means it can display practically every color in modern HDR content, resulting in strikingly natural and vibrant images.

The Epson, limited to the older Rec.709 color space, can't match this range of colors. However, within its limitations, it produces accurate and pleasing images that will satisfy most viewers. Think of it like comparing a professional DSLR camera to a high-end smartphone - both can take great photos, but the DSLR has more potential in the right hands.

Resolution and Detail

Both projectors advertise 4K resolution, but achieve it differently. The Samsung uses DLP pixel-shifting to create true 4K images, while the Epson enhances a 1080p image to near-4K quality through its own pixel-shifting technology. In practice, the Samsung shows a slight edge in detail, particularly noticeable with 4K content when viewed up close.

Gaming Considerations

Surprisingly, the less expensive Epson takes the lead for gaming. Its 16.7ms input lag is remarkably low for a projector, making it suitable for all but the most competitive gaming. The Samsung's 53ms lag, while not terrible, is noticeable in fast-paced games.

Audio Solutions

The Samsung Premiere 9 shows its premium nature with a sophisticated 40W 2.2.2 channel audio system supporting Dolby Atmos. This isn't just marketing - the sound quality is genuinely impressive for a built-in system, creating a wide soundstage with decent bass and even some height effects.

The Epson LS800 offers a more basic 20W stereo system that's fine for casual viewing but will likely want upgrading for serious movie watching. However, this could be seen as an advantage if you're planning to use external speakers anyway.

Smart Features and Connectivity

Both projectors offer modern smart platforms, though their approaches differ. The Samsung uses its Tizen OS, which provides a polished, TV-like experience with major streaming apps built-in. The Epson's Android TV implementation offers more flexibility and app options but can feel slightly less refined.

Both provide multiple HDMI inputs suitable for 4K/60Hz content, though neither supports HDMI 2.1 features like variable refresh rate or 4K/120Hz gaming.

Value Proposition

At roughly half the price of the Samsung, the Epson represents exceptional value for most users. Its higher brightness, excellent gaming performance, and solid image quality make it a compelling choice for mixed-use environments.

The Samsung justifies its premium price for serious home theater enthusiasts who prioritize color accuracy and contrast, especially in dedicated viewing rooms. Its superior audio system also adds value if you're not planning to use external speakers.

How to Decide

Choose the Samsung if:

• You're creating a dedicated home theater
• Color accuracy and HDR performance are top priorities
• You want premium built-in audio
• Budget allows for the best available technology

Choose the Epson if:

• You'll frequently watch with ambient light
• Gaming is a priority
• You're connecting external speakers anyway
• Value is a key consideration

Both projectors represent impressive achievements in UST technology, but they serve different needs. The Epson offers tremendous value and versatility, while the Samsung delivers premium performance for the discerning enthusiast. Your choice should ultimately depend on your viewing environment, usage patterns, and budget constraints.

Samsung Premiere 9 4K Ultra Short Throw Laser Projector Deals and Prices

Epson EpiqVision Ultra LS800 3LCD Laser Projector Deals and Prices