Choosing Between Ring and Nest Battery Doorbells: A Complete Guide

The Evolution of Smart Doorbells

The humble doorbell has come a long way. Today's smart video doorbells are sophisticated security devices that let you see, hear, and talk to visitors whether you're home or not. Released in early 2023, the Ring Battery Doorbell Plus ($149) and Google Nest Doorbell Battery ($179) represent the latest evolution in this rapidly advancing category.

Understanding What Matters

Before diving into the specifics, let's talk about what makes a smart doorbell truly useful. The core features are video quality (so you can clearly see visitors and packages), reliable motion detection (to alert you when something's happening), and battery life (because nobody wants to charge their doorbell weekly). But there's more to consider - from smart home integration to subscription costs.

Video Quality: A Clear Difference

The Ring Battery Doorbell Plus takes the lead here with its 1536p HD video resolution - that's notably sharper than the Nest's 960x1280. What does this mean in real terms? Ring's higher resolution means you'll see more detail in faces and package labels, which could be crucial for security footage.

Both devices offer HDR (High Dynamic Range) support, which helps balance bright and dark areas in the image. However, Ring's implementation of color night vision gives it an edge in low-light situations, though some might find the artificially colored nighttime footage less useful than Nest's clear black-and-white infrared approach.

Field of view is another important consideration:

• Ring: 150° horizontal and vertical
• Nest: 145° diagonal

Ring's "head-to-toe" viewing angle means you're less likely to miss packages left right at your doorstep, while still maintaining good coverage of your porch area.

Battery Life and Charging

Here's where design philosophy really diverges:

The Ring Battery Doorbell Plus uses a removable battery pack that you can easily swap out. This means you can purchase a spare battery ($35) and never have downtime - just swap the depleted battery for a charged one in seconds. Battery life typically ranges from 2-6 months, depending on settings and activity levels.

The Nest Doorbell Battery has a built-in battery that requires removing the entire doorbell for charging. While this design choice makes the unit more weather-resistant, it means your doorbell is offline during charging (which takes about 5 hours). Battery life averages 2-3 months under normal use.

Smart Features and AI Capabilities

Both doorbells have gotten smarter since their release, with regular software updates adding features and improving performance.

Nest stands out with its free intelligent alerts, which can distinguish between:

• People
• Packages
• Vehicles
• Animals

These alerts work without a subscription, which is a significant advantage. Ring requires a paid subscription (Ring Protect) for similar features, though its implementation includes more detailed motion zones and person detection.

Subscription Considerations

This is a crucial factor in long-term ownership costs:

Ring Protect Plans:

• Basic: $3/month or $30/year
• Plus: $10/month or $100/year
• Required for video recording and smart alerts

Nest Aware:

• Basic: $6/month or $60/year
• Plus: $12/month or $120/year
• Optional but adds facial recognition and longer video history

Installation and Setup

Both doorbells are designed for DIY installation, supporting either battery-only or hardwired configurations. Key differences:

Ring:

• Includes multiple mounting brackets
• Supports existing doorbell chimes when hardwired
• More flexible placement options due to removable battery

Nest:

• Sleeker mounting system
• Requires Google Home app for setup
• May need a Nest Mini speaker for chime functionality

Smart Home Integration

Your existing smart home ecosystem might be the deciding factor:

The Ring Battery Doorbell Plus works seamlessly with:

• Amazon Alexa
• Fire TV devices
• Ring security systems
• Echo Show displays

The Nest Doorbell Battery integrates with:

• Google Assistant
• Chromecast devices
• Other Nest products
• Google Home displays

Performance in Real-World Use

After extensive testing and real-world use, some key performance differences emerge:

Response Time:

• Ring typically responds faster to motion events
• Nest has slightly better accuracy in person detection
• Both handle Wi-Fi connections reliably

Night Vision:

• Ring's color night vision provides more detail but can look artificial
• Nest's traditional IR approach gives clearer black-and-white images

Audio Quality:

• Both offer good two-way audio
• Ring has slightly better noise cancellation
• Nest handles wind noise better

Recent Updates and Improvements

Since their release, both companies have pushed regular software updates:

Ring has added:

• Enhanced motion detection algorithms
• Improved battery life optimization
• Better package detection accuracy

Nest has introduced:

• More reliable person detection
• Improved battery management
• Enhanced night vision performance

How to Decide

Consider these scenarios:

Choose the Ring Battery Doorbell Plus if:

• You're already invested in the Amazon/Alexa ecosystem
• Video quality is your top priority
• You want the convenience of swappable batteries
• You don't mind paying for a subscription

Choose the Nest Doorbell Battery if:

• You use Google Home devices
• You want free intelligent alerts
• You prefer a sleeker design
• You can live with lower resolution video

Final Thoughts

Both doorbells represent the current state of the art in their category, but they approach the challenge differently. Ring focuses on hardware capabilities and ecosystem integration, while Nest emphasizes smart features and free functionality.

The decision often comes down to your existing smart home setup and whether you prioritize video quality (Ring) or smart features (Nest). Either way, both devices will significantly upgrade your front door security and convenience.

For most users, the ecosystem match will be the deciding factor - if you're heavily invested in Amazon's ecosystem, the Ring makes more sense. If you're a Google Home user, the Nest's tight integration will likely outweigh its lower resolution.

Remember that both companies regularly update their devices, so the feature gap may continue to evolve over time. Consider your current needs but also think about which ecosystem you're likely to expand into in the future.

Ring Battery Doorbell Plus Smart Video Doorbell Deals and Prices

Google Nest Doorbell Battery Video Doorbell Camera Deals and Prices