Choosing Between the Revel M16 and Klipsch RP-600M II: A Detailed Comparison

When it comes to bookshelf speakers under $350, two models frequently come up in discussions: the Revel Concerta2 M16 ($296) and the Klipsch RP-600M II ($331). Let's dive into what makes each special and help you decide which might work better for your needs.

Understanding Bookshelf Speakers in 2024

Bookshelf speakers remain the sweet spot for many audio enthusiasts, offering an excellent balance of performance and practicality. They're large enough to produce satisfying sound but small enough to work in most rooms. The key is understanding how different design approaches affect real-world performance.

Release Timeline and Evolution

The Revel M16 has been around longer, drawing from Revel's premium Performa3 series technology. Meanwhile, the Klipsch RP-600M II represents a recent update to their popular Reference Premiere line, with notable improvements to their signature horn design and woofer configuration.

Core Technical Differences

Driver Design and Implementation

The Revel M16 takes a traditional audiophile approach with its 6.5" aluminum cone woofer and 1" aluminum dome tweeter. The aluminum drivers offer excellent rigidity and low mass, which helps prevent distortion at higher volumes. Their acoustic lens waveguide (think of it as a specially shaped sound projector) helps control how sound spreads into your room.

The Klipsch RP-600M II uses their distinctive horn-loaded tweeter design - imagine a megaphone shape that helps project high frequencies more efficiently. Their 6.5" Cerametallic woofer (a ceramic-coated aluminum cone) provides impressive bass impact. The newer model features a 70% larger voice coil and improved motor structure, which helps control cone movement more precisely.

Efficiency and Amplification Needs

Here's where we see a major difference that affects real-world use. The Klipsch's 94dB sensitivity rating means it needs far less power to play loud compared to the Revel's 86dB rating. In practical terms, the Klipsch will play noticeably louder with the same amount of power.

If you're using a modest amplifier (say, 50 watts per channel or less), the Klipsch will be more dynamic. The Revel, while still excellent, really benefits from more powerful amplification to show its full potential.

Sound Character and Performance

Tonal Balance

The Revel M16 aims for neutrality above all else. Its frequency response is remarkably flat, meaning it reproduces music very close to how it was recorded. This accuracy makes it excellent for hearing exactly what's in your recordings, though some might find this approach less exciting with certain types of music.

The Klipsch takes a more dynamic approach. While the II version is more refined than its predecessor, it still maintains the engaging, forward sound Klipsch is known for. Bass feels more prominent, and high frequencies tend to be more energetic, which can make rock and pop music especially engaging.

Imaging and Soundstage

Both speakers handle spatial presentation differently. The Revel creates a precise, well-defined image between the speakers. Instruments and vocals are locked in place with excellent focus. The Klipsch, with its horn design, tends to create a wider soundstage that can extend beyond the speaker boundaries, though sometimes with slightly less precise positioning.

Room Interaction

The Revel's controlled dispersion pattern makes it easier to place in challenging rooms, particularly those with nearby walls. The Klipsch's wider dispersion can create a more immersive sound field but might interact more with room acoustics, requiring more careful placement.

Home Theater Considerations

In a home theater context, both speakers have different strengths. The Klipsch's higher sensitivity makes it easier to achieve reference-level volumes, and its dynamic presentation works well with movie soundtracks. The horn design also helps with dialogue clarity.

The Revel's accuracy and precise imaging can create a more convincing soundstage for movies, though you might need more powerful amplification to achieve the same impact as the Klipsch. Its neutral character also makes it easier to match with other speakers in a surround setup.

Value Proposition

At their current prices, both speakers represent excellent value but for different reasons. The Revel M16 offers exceptional accuracy and build quality at $296, making it a strong choice for critical listening. The Klipsch RP-600M II at $331 provides outstanding dynamics and efficiency, especially valuable for home theater use or when using lower-powered amplifiers.

How to Decide

Consider these key factors when making your choice:

1. Amplifier Power: If you have a modest amplifier (under 50W per channel), the Klipsch will be more dynamic and engaging. The Revel needs more power to shine.
2. Room Size: In larger rooms (over 300 square feet), the Klipsch's efficiency advantage becomes more important. The Revel works exceptionally well in small to medium rooms.
3. Listening Preferences:
   • For classical, jazz, and acoustic music: Consider the Revel's accuracy
   • For rock, pop, and home theater: The Klipsch's dynamic presentation might be more engaging
4. System Integration:
   • For a pure music system: Either works well, depending on your preferred sound signature
   • For home theater: The Klipsch's efficiency makes it easier to achieve theater-like dynamics

The beauty of these speakers is that neither is a wrong choice - they just serve different preferences and needs. The Revel excels in accuracy and refinement, while the Klipsch delivers excitement and dynamics. Your choice should align with your specific situation and listening preferences rather than just specs alone.

Remember, speaker choice is personal, and what works best in one situation might not be ideal in another. Consider your room, equipment, and listening habits carefully when making your decision.

Revel Concerta2 M16 Bookshelf Speaker Deals and Prices

Klipsch RP-600M II Bookshelf Speakers - Pair Deals and Prices