Choosing Between the Revel M16 and JBL Stage 240B: A Detailed Comparison

When shopping for bookshelf speakers, the Revel Concerta2 M16 and JBL Stage 2 240B represent two distinct price points and engineering approaches. Let's explore how these speakers stack up and which might be right for your needs.

Understanding Bookshelf Speakers in 2024

Bookshelf speakers remain a cornerstone of quality home audio, offering a sweet spot between performance and space efficiency. Despite the surge in soundbars and wireless speakers, traditional passive bookshelf speakers continue to deliver superior sound quality for their size and price.

These two models showcase different philosophies: the M16 represents Revel's premium engineering at a mid-tier price point, while the 240B demonstrates JBL's approach to value-oriented performance.

Sound Quality Deep Dive

Frequency Response and Accuracy

The Revel M16's larger 6.5" woofer delivers impressive bass down to 55Hz (-3dB), with usable response to 45Hz. This means you'll hear most music's fundamental bass notes without a subwoofer. The aluminum dome tweeter, paired with Revel's sophisticated waveguide (which helps control how sound spreads into the room), produces exceptionally smooth high frequencies.

The JBL 240B, with its smaller 4.5" woofer, can't quite match this low-end extension. However, its similar aluminum tweeter design provides good clarity in the high frequencies, though without quite the refinement of the Revel's more advanced waveguide technology.

Imaging and Soundstage

Here's where the Revel's engineering shines. Its fourth-generation waveguide technology creates a remarkably precise soundstage - that three-dimensional space where instruments and voices appear to float between and around the speakers. The M16's computer-optimized driver positioning helps create a more coherent sound field, making it easier to forget you're listening to speakers at all.

The JBL 240B produces a good soundstage for its price point but doesn't quite achieve the same level of precision. You'll still get a nice stereo image, but instrument placement isn't as sharply defined.

Technical Innovation and Heritage

The Revel M16, released around 2016, brought down technology from their higher-end Performa3 series. The waveguide design, in particular, represents years of research at Harman's advanced research facilities. While not the newest model, its technical sophistication remains competitive.

JBL's Stage 2 240B is a more recent release, incorporating some trickle-down technology from their professional line. The HDI (High-Definition Imaging) waveguide, while simpler than the Revel's design, still benefits from JBL's extensive experience in professional audio.

Real-World Performance

Music Listening

For critical music listening, the Revel M16 pulls ahead significantly. Its ability to reproduce subtle details and maintain clarity during complex passages makes it ideal for everything from classical to jazz to rock. The larger woofer provides more impact on bass-heavy music without straining.

The JBL 240B handles music competently but shows its limitations with more demanding material. Bass-heavy genres might require a subwoofer, though the speaker handles vocals and midrange instruments well.

Home Theater Use

Both speakers can work well in a home theater setup, but in different roles. The M16's superior dynamics and bass extension make it an excellent choice for front left and right channels, where it can handle both music and movie soundtracks with authority.

The 240B shines as a surround speaker or in smaller rooms. Its more compact size and lower price make it practical to buy multiple pairs for a surround setup, and its efficiency means it works well with most AV receivers.

Value Proposition

At their respective price points ($900 MSRP for the M16 vs $240 for the 240B), each speaker offers distinct value:

Revel M16

• Superior technical performance
• Better resale value
• Long-term satisfaction for critical listeners
• Often available significantly below MSRP

JBL 240B

• Excellent performance per dollar
• More flexible for multi-speaker setups
• Easier to drive with modest amplification
• Perfect entry point to quality audio

Installation and Setup Considerations

Both speakers benefit from proper positioning, but the M16 is more demanding. It performs best with high-quality amplification and some space behind it for the rear port to breathe. The 240B is more forgiving of placement and amplification, making it easier to integrate into existing systems.

How to Decide

Choose the Revel M16 if:

• Sound quality is your primary concern
• You have a quality amplifier
• Your room is medium to large sized
• Budget allows for investment in long-term satisfaction

Choose the JBL 240B if:

• You're building a surround system on a budget
• Your room is smaller
• You're using a modest receiver or amplifier
• You want solid performance without a big investment

Final Thoughts

The Revel M16 and JBL Stage 2 240B each excel in their respective price categories. The M16 represents a significant step up in absolute performance, justified for serious listeners who will appreciate its refinement. The 240B offers impressive value, delivering much of what makes bookshelf speakers great at a more accessible price point.

For most users, the decision will come down to budget and use case. Those seeking the best possible stereo performance should stretch for the M16 if possible. Those building a complete home theater or seeking good performance on a budget will find the 240B more than satisfactory.

Remember, both speakers will benefit from proper setup and positioning, and either can serve as the foundation of an enjoyable audio system for years to come.

Revel Concerta2 M16 Bookshelf Speaker Deals and Prices

JBL Stage 2 240B 2-Way 4.5" Bookshelf Loudspeaker - Pair Deals and Prices