Premium vs. Budget Bookshelf Speakers: A Detailed Comparison

Making Sense of Two Very Different Approaches

When setting up a home audio system, bookshelf speakers often provide the perfect balance of sound quality and space efficiency. Today, we're comparing two distinctly different approaches: the premium Revel Concerta2 M16 ($900/pair) and the budget-friendly Edifier R1280TS ($91/pair).

Understanding the Category

Bookshelf speakers, despite their name, are designed to sit on stands or shelves at ear level rather than actually on bookshelves (which can create unwanted sound reflections). They serve as the foundation of many high-quality audio systems, offering a compelling mix of performance and practicality when floor-standing towers aren't feasible.

The biggest distinction in our comparison is that the Revel M16 is a passive speaker requiring separate amplification, while the Edifier R1280TS is powered, meaning it has built-in amplifiers. This fundamental difference shapes not just how they're used, but who they're best for.

Sound Quality Deep Dive

High-Frequency Performance

The Revel M16 uses a 1-inch aluminum dome tweeter with an advanced waveguide (a specially shaped housing that controls how sound spreads into the room). This technology, derived from Revel's more expensive Performa3 series, delivers exceptional clarity and detail in the treble region. The aluminum construction helps avoid the slight softening that some cloth dome tweeters exhibit.

In contrast, the Edifier R1280TS employs a 13mm silk dome tweeter. While silk domes are generally known for smooth, non-fatiguing sound, they typically can't match the precision and detail of a well-designed metal dome. In listening tests, this difference becomes apparent on cymbal crashes and string instruments, where the Revel reveals more texture and natural decay of notes.

Midrange and Bass

The M16's 6.5-inch aluminum woofer provides remarkably clean midrange and surprisingly deep bass for its size. The speaker can reach down to 55Hz (-3dB), which means it reproduces most music's fundamental notes without requiring a subwoofer. The rigid aluminum cone helps prevent distortion during complex passages.

The Edifier uses a 4-inch woofer that, while adequate for casual listening, can't move as much air or maintain composure during demanding passages. Its frequency response only extends to 60Hz, and even then, the bass isn't as controlled as the Revel's. This becomes particularly noticeable on orchestral music or modern electronic tracks with deep bass lines.

Real-World Performance

Home Theater Use

The Revel M16 excels in home theater applications, particularly when matched with a quality AV receiver. Its precision and dynamics make movie dialogue crystal clear while handling action sequences with authority. The speaker's excellent off-axis response (how it sounds when you're not sitting directly in front) helps create a convincing surround sound field.

The Edifier R1280TS can certainly function in a basic home theater setup, but its limitations become apparent during dynamic movie scenes. The built-in amplification (21W RMS per speaker) restricts maximum volume and dynamic range compared to the Revel paired with a proper receiver.

Music Reproduction

For music, the differences become even more pronounced. The Revel M16 creates a precise soundstage (the illusion of instruments positioned in space) with excellent separation between instruments. It's particularly impressive with complex orchestral works, where you can easily follow individual instrumental lines.

The Edifier performs respectably with simpler music at moderate volumes but starts to compress and lose clarity when pushed. It's perfectly enjoyable for background listening or desktop use but doesn't provide the same level of engagement for critical listening sessions.

Setup and System Integration

Revel M16 Considerations

• Requires external amplification (50-120W recommended)
• Benefits from quality speaker stands
• Flexible placement options due to sophisticated port design
• Can be part of a growing system
• Works well with subwoofers due to controlled rolloff

Edifier R1280TS Features

• Built-in amplification
• Simple RCA inputs
• Basic tone controls
• Remote control included
• Subwoofer output included

Technology and Innovation

The Revel M16, while not the newest model (released around 2015), incorporates several advanced technologies that remain impressive today:

• Fourth-generation Acoustic Lens waveguide
• Computer-optimized driver positioning
• Sophisticated crossover design
• Constant Pressure Gradient port design

The Edifier, as a more recent budget design, focuses on convenience features:

• Bluetooth connectivity
• Digital signal processing
• Auto-standby power saving
• Integrated amplification

Value Proposition

The Revel M16 at $900/pair (plus amplification) represents a significant investment but delivers reference-quality sound that competes with much more expensive speakers. It's a speaker that could serve as the foundation of a high-end system for many years.

The Edifier R1280TS at $91/pair offers remarkable value as a complete solution. While it can't match the Revel's performance, it provides enjoyable sound quality that far exceeds typical computer speakers or soundbars in its price range.

How to Decide

Choose the Revel M16 if:

• Sound quality is your primary concern
• You're building a serious audio system
• You have (or plan to get) quality amplification
• You want long-term flexibility
• Critical listening is important to you

Choose the Edifier R1280TS if:

• You need an immediate, complete solution
• Budget is a major constraint
• You're primarily using them at a desk
• Convenience matters more than ultimate sound quality
• You're new to better audio and want to start simple

Conclusion

These speakers represent opposite ends of the bookshelf speaker spectrum. The Revel M16 is a refined audiophile tool that requires proper amplification and setup but rewards with exceptional sound quality. The Edifier R1280TS is a practical, budget-friendly solution that sacrifices ultimate performance for convenience and value.

For those serious about sound quality and willing to invest in proper amplification, the Revel M16 offers performance that will satisfy for years to come. If you're looking for a simple upgrade from basic computer speakers or want decent sound without complexity, the Edifier R1280TS provides remarkable value and convenience.

Remember that speaker choice is highly personal, and if possible, listening to both options in your intended space is always the best way to make a final decision.

Revel Concerta2 M16 Bookshelf Speaker Deals and Prices

Edifier R1280TS Powered Bookshelf Speakers Deals and Prices