When it comes to high-end portable audio, the $129.99 Marshall Stockwell II and $149.95 Bose SoundLink Max represent two different approaches to solving the same problem: delivering great sound on the go. Let's explore how these speakers stack up in 2024, considering their features, technology, and real-world performance.
The portable speaker market has changed dramatically since the Marshall Stockwell II launched in 2019. Back then, IPX4 water resistance (protection from splashes) was standard, and Bluetooth 5.0 was cutting-edge. Fast forward to 2021 when the Bose SoundLink Max arrived, bringing IP67 protection (full waterproofing and dust resistance) and Bluetooth 5.4, showing how quickly standards evolved.
The Stockwell II employs a unique three-amplifier system: one 10W amp for the woofer and two 5W amps for the tweeters. This configuration, called "True Stereophonic," creates an impressive stereo field despite the speaker's compact size. The sound signature emphasizes clarity in mids and highs, making it excellent for vocal-heavy music and acoustic performances.
The physical EQ controls are a standout feature - separate knobs for bass and treble let you dial in your preferred sound without reaching for your phone. This analog approach might seem old-school, but it's incredibly practical when your hands are wet or dirty.
The SoundLink Max takes a different path, utilizing Bose's proprietary digital signal processing (DSP) to optimize sound automatically. While you can't manually adjust the EQ, the speaker's internal processing constantly adapts to deliver balanced audio across different volumes. The larger cabinet size (about 30% bigger than the Marshall) allows for more powerful bass response and higher maximum volume.
A unique feature is Bose's SimpleSync technology, which lets you pair the speaker with other Bose products for synchronized playback - particularly useful in a home theater setup as auxiliary speakers.
In living room settings, the Marshall Stockwell II shines with its ability to create an intimate listening experience. The adjustable EQ helps compensate for room acoustics, and the 80 dB maximum volume is plenty for indoor spaces. However, bass response can feel thin when playing hip-hop or electronic music, even with the bass turned up.
The Bose SoundLink Max delivers a more room-filling sound, with better bass extension that you can actually feel. Its wider soundstage makes it more suitable for home theater use, where it can serve as a temporary soundbar replacement. The higher maximum volume handles larger indoor spaces without distortion.
Here's where the differences become stark. The Marshall's IPX4 rating means you'll need to be careful around water, and its slimmer sound profile can get lost in open spaces. The physical controls, while nice, can collect dust and debris outdoors.
The Bose's IP67 rating means you can use it at the beach or pool without worry - it can even survive being submerged in water for 30 minutes. The more powerful output and stronger bass carry better outdoors, making it the clear choice for outdoor gatherings.
Both speakers feature current Bluetooth standards, but implement them differently:
Marshall Stockwell II:
Bose SoundLink Max:
The $20 price difference between these speakers is less significant than their functional differences. The Marshall Stockwell II offers better value for indoor users who appreciate sound customization and classic styling. Its quick-charge feature is particularly valuable for those who forget to charge overnight.
The Bose SoundLink Max justifies its higher price through superior durability, more powerful sound, and newer technology. The ability to charge other devices and pair with other Bose products adds versatility that might be worth the premium for some users.
Consider choosing the Marshall Stockwell II if:
Opt for the Bose SoundLink Max when:
Both speakers represent different philosophies in portable audio. The Marshall Stockwell II embraces classic design and user control, while the Bose SoundLink Max pushes toward modern features and durability. Your choice should align with your primary use case rather than small price differences.
For indoor listening and audio enthusiasts who love tweaking their sound, the Marshall's approach is compelling. For versatile outdoor use and more powerful audio, the Bose makes more sense. Either way, both speakers deliver premium audio experiences that justify their price points.
| Marshall Stockwell II | Bose SoundLink Max |
|---|---|
| Price - Initial Investment | |
| $129.99 | $149.95 |
| Weight - Impacts portability and ease of transport | |
| 3.04 lbs (more portable) | 4.9 lbs (less portable but more substantial) |
| Water Resistance - Critical for outdoor use | |
| IPX4 (splash resistant only) | IP67 (fully waterproof, dustproof) |
| Battery Life - Determines usage between charges | |
| 20 hours at moderate volume, 6 hours from 20-min charge | 20 hours at moderate volume, 3 hours at max volume |
| Sound Output - Affects room coverage and outdoor use | |
| 80 dB @ 1m, better for small-medium spaces | Higher output, suitable for larger spaces |
| Audio Features - Sound customization options | |
| Physical bass/treble controls, True Stereophonic | SimpleSync, Digital Signal Processing, aptX Adaptive |
| Amplification - Determines sound quality and power | |
| 1x10W (woofer) + 2x5W (tweeters) | Not specified, but higher overall output |
| Connectivity - Affects device compatibility | |
| Bluetooth 5.0, 30ft range, multi-host | Bluetooth 5.4, extended range, multi-point |
| Additional Features - Extra functionality | |
| Quick charging, analog controls | Power bank function, Bose app control |
| Build Quality - Durability and design | |
| Premium materials, vintage design | Rugged construction, modern design |
| Best Use Case - Primary application | |
| Indoor use, style-conscious users, audio enthusiasts | Outdoor activities, larger spaces, bass-heavy music |
The $149.95 Bose SoundLink Max is better suited for home theater use due to its higher output volume, stronger bass response, and wider soundstage. It also features SimpleSync technology for pairing with other Bose home theater products. The $129.99 Marshall Stockwell II is more suited for personal listening.
The Bose SoundLink Max delivers fuller sound with stronger bass, while the Marshall Stockwell II offers clearer mids and highs. The Bose performs better in larger spaces, while the Marshall excels in intimate settings.
Yes, but the Bose SoundLink Max is better suited with IP67 waterproof/dustproof rating and louder output. The Marshall Stockwell II has only IPX4 splash resistance and lower volume output.
Both the Marshall Stockwell II and Bose SoundLink Max offer 20 hours of battery life at moderate volume. However, the Marshall features quick charging (6 hours from 20 minutes), while the Bose drops to 3 hours at maximum volume.
Both speakers can connect to TVs with Bluetooth capability. The Bose SoundLink Max performs better as a TV speaker due to its stronger output and bass response. For permanent TV use, a dedicated soundbar would be recommended.
The Marshall Stockwell II is more portable at 3.04 lbs compared to the Bose SoundLink Max at 4.9 lbs. Both include carrying handles, but the Marshall's lighter weight makes it easier to transport.
The Marshall Stockwell II features physical knobs for bass and treble adjustment. The Bose SoundLink Max uses digital signal processing and can be adjusted through the Bose app.
At $129.99, the Marshall Stockwell II offers better value for indoor use and audio customization. The Bose SoundLink Max at $149.95 justifies its higher price through better durability and stronger sound output.
Yes, but the Bose SoundLink Max is better suited due to its stronger bass response and wider soundstage. The Marshall Stockwell II can work for personal viewing but lacks the power for home theater use.
Both support multi-device connectivity. The Marshall Stockwell II uses Bluetooth 5.0 with multi-host functionality, while the Bose SoundLink Max uses Bluetooth 5.4 with multi-point connection.
The Bose SoundLink Max is more durable with IP67 waterproof/dustproof rating and rugged construction. The Marshall Stockwell II has IPX4 splash resistance and is more suited for indoor use.
The Bose SoundLink Max can integrate with other Bose products through SimpleSync technology. The Marshall Stockwell II operates as a standalone speaker without multi-speaker connectivity options.
We've done our best to create useful and informative comparisons to help you decide what product to buy. Our research uses advanced automated methods to create this comparison and perfection is not possible - please contact us for corrections or questions. These are the sites we've researched in the creation of this article: bestbuy.com - stuff.tv - idownloadblog.com - stereoguide.com - kendallgiles.com - termagoods.com - aplaze.com - manua.ls - youtube.com - sg.tcacoustic.asia - marshall.com - youtube.com - staples.com - 365wholesale.com - bose.com - bose.com - bestbuy.com - soundguys.com - staples.com - techforless.com - bestbuy.com - assets.bose.com
