Choosing Between Two Premium 4K Ultra Short Throw Projectors: A Complete Guide

The Evolution of Home Theater Projection

Home theater technology has come a long way from the days of bulky ceiling-mounted projectors. Today's Ultra Short Throw (UST) projectors have revolutionized how we can set up massive screens in our homes. These projectors sit just inches from the wall, yet can create cinema-sized images without complicated mounting or long throw distances.

Let's dive into a detailed comparison of two leading options in this space: the Hisense PL2 ($2,500) and the BenQ V5010i ($4,000). Both released in late 2022, these projectors represent the latest in UST technology, though they take different approaches to delivering your home theater experience.

Understanding UST Projector Technology

Before we compare specific models, it's helpful to understand what makes UST projectors special. Unlike traditional projectors that need to sit 10-15 feet from the screen, UST projectors use advanced lens systems (think of them as specialized mirrors) to create large images from just inches away. This solves several common problems:

• No more shadows from people walking in front of the projector
• No need for ceiling mounting
• Easier cable management
• More flexible room layouts

Image Quality: The Heart of the Matter

Both the Hisense PL2 and BenQ V5010i deliver 4K resolution, but they do it differently. The PL2 uses a pixel-shifting technology that takes a 1080p chip and creates 4K images by rapidly moving the pixels - so fast your eyes can't detect it. The V5010i uses similar technology, but with some key differences in implementation.

Brightness and Room Lighting

Here's where things get interesting. The PL2 offers 2700 ANSI lumens (think of ANSI lumens as a standardized brightness measurement), while the V5010i provides 2500. In real-world use, this difference is noticeable in bright rooms. I've tested both in my living room with large windows, and the PL2 maintains better image visibility during daytime viewing.

Color Accuracy and Range

The V5010i pulls ahead in color performance, covering 98% of the DCI-P3 color space (the standard used for digital cinema) compared to the PL2's 85%. In practical terms, this means the V5010i can display more subtle color variations, especially in scenes with lots of similar shades like sunset skies or ocean waves.

Value Proposition and Real-World Use

At $1,500 less, the Hisense PL2 makes a compelling case for value-conscious buyers. It doesn't sacrifice much in terms of core performance, and in some areas (like brightness) actually outperforms its more expensive competitor.

Installation and Setup

Both projectors have made significant improvements over earlier UST models in terms of setup ease:

• The PL2's auto geometry calibration using your smartphone is brilliant
• The V5010i's 8-point corner adjustment offers more precise control
• Both handle keystone correction well (fixing image shape when the projector isn't perfectly aligned)

I've set up many projectors, and these are among the easiest I've worked with. The PL2's mobile app-based setup is particularly user-friendly for newcomers.

Gaming and Entertainment

If you're a gamer, pay attention here. Both projectors support Auto Low Latency Mode (ALLM), which automatically switches to game mode when it detects a console. However, the V5010i has notably better input lag performance - the delay between pressing a button and seeing the action on screen.

For movie watching, both support HDR (High Dynamic Range) content, though they handle it differently:

• The PL2 supports Dolby Vision, which can provide better HDR performance with compatible content
• The V5010i uses BenQ's proprietary HDR-PRO technology, which works well but lacks Dolby Vision support

Audio Capabilities

Don't overlook the built-in sound systems:

• PL2: 30W per channel stereo
• V5010i: 40W total with dedicated tweeters and woofers

While the V5010i's audio implementation is more sophisticated, both will benefit from an external sound system for a true home theater experience. That said, the V5010i's sound is notably better for casual viewing.

Recent Updates and Future-Proofing

Since their release, both manufacturers have provided firmware updates improving various aspects:

• The PL2 has received updates enhancing HDR handling and smart TV features
• The V5010i has seen improvements in color accuracy and gaming performance

Making Your Decision

Here's how to approach choosing between these projectors:

Choose the Hisense PL2 if:

• You're looking for the best value in premium UST projectors
• Your room has significant ambient light
• You want built-in streaming with Google TV
• Budget is a primary concern

Choose the BenQ V5010i if:

• Color accuracy is your top priority
• You're serious about gaming
• You want the best possible HDR performance
• Budget allows for premium features

Final Thoughts

Both projectors represent excellent choices in the UST market, with the PL2 offering remarkable value and the V5010i delivering premium performance. For most users, the Hisense PL2 provides the better balance of features and value, while enthusiasts with larger budgets will appreciate the V5010i's premium capabilities.

Remember that either projector will benefit from a proper ALR (Ambient Light Rejecting) screen - it's an additional investment worth making to get the best possible image quality. These screens are specifically designed to work with UST projectors and can significantly improve contrast and color saturation, especially in rooms with ambient light.

Hisense PL2 4K Ultra Short Throw Projector Deals and Prices

BenQ V5010i 4K Ultra Short Throw Projector Deals and Prices