High-End vs. Budget Bookshelf Speakers: A Detailed Comparison

When it comes to bookshelf speakers, the market spans from affordable powered units to premium passive models. Today, we're comparing the high-end Bowers & Wilkins 707 S2 ($959) with the budget-friendly Edifier R1280TS ($91), exploring why there's such a significant price difference and what that means for your listening experience.

Understanding the Category

Bookshelf speakers, despite their name, aren't necessarily meant to sit on bookshelves. They're compact speakers designed for placement on stands or elevated surfaces, offering a sweet spot between room-friendly size and quality sound reproduction. The key distinction in our comparison is between passive speakers (requiring an external amplifier) and powered speakers (with built-in amplification).

Technology and Innovation

The B&W 707 S2, released in 2017, represents B&W's trickle-down technology from their flagship 800 Series Diamond line. Its Continuum cone (replacing the previous Kevlar design) marked a significant advance in driver material, reducing unwanted resonances and providing more natural sound. The Carbon Dome tweeter, pushing breakup threshold to 47kHz, delivers exceptional high-frequency detail.

Meanwhile, the Edifier R1280TS takes a more straightforward approach with conventional drivers but adds modern conveniences like remote control and tone adjustment. While lacking cutting-edge materials, it incorporates solid engineering principles in its powered design.

Performance Deep-Dive

Sound Quality

The 707 S2's technical superiority shows in several ways:

• Imaging: Precise placement of instruments and voices in the soundstage
• Detail retrieval: Subtle nuances in recordings become apparent
• Dynamic range: Better handling of quiet-to-loud transitions
• Frequency extension: Smoother highs and more controlled bass

The R1280TS performs admirably for its price:

• Pleasant overall sound signature
• Good bass presence for size
• Adjustable tone controls for preference matching
• Limited but adequate dynamic range

Room Integration

The 707 S2 benefits from proper amplification and placement:

• Needs space to breathe (at least 12" from walls)
• Stands are crucial for optimal performance
• More flexible with room placement due to superior driver control

The R1280TS is more forgiving:

• Works well in desktop settings
• Less critical of placement
• Built-in amplification matched to drivers

Home Theater Application

For home theater use, the 707 S2 excels:

• Can be part of a matched surround system
• Handles movie dynamics well
• Integrates seamlessly with subwoofers
• Clarity crucial for dialogue

The R1280TS has limitations:

• Limited power for movie dynamics
• No easy way to integrate into surround sound
• Better suited as TV speakers in small rooms

Value Consideration

Looking at total cost of ownership, the 707 S2 requires:

• Quality amplification ($500+ recommended)
• Speaker stands ($200+ for proper ones)
• Good speaker cables ($50+)
• Possible room treatment

The R1280TS needs:

• Just source connection cables
• Optional subwoofer if desired

However, the 707 S2 provides:

• Long-term investment potential
• Higher resale value
• Upgrade flexibility
• Superior performance ceiling

Real-World Usage

In practice, the 707 S2 shows its worth in:

• Critical listening sessions
• Movie watching
• Complex musical passages
• Large room applications

The R1280TS shines in:

• Desktop computer setups
• Small room music playback
• Gaming
• Background listening

Technical Innovation Impact

The 707 S2's advanced technologies make tangible differences:

• Continuum cone provides clearer midrange
• Carbon dome tweeter extends frequency response
• Flowport reduces port noise
• Cabinet bracing minimizes resonance

The R1280TS focuses on practical features:

• Digital amplification for efficiency
• Bass/treble controls for sound tailoring
• Multiple inputs for connectivity
• Remote control convenience

Making the Choice

Consider the 707 S2 if:

• You're building a serious audio system
• Future upgradeability matters
• Critical listening is important
• Budget allows for quality amplification
• Room size and acoustics are suitable

Choose the R1280TS when:

• Immediate, complete solution needed
• Budget is limited
• Space is tight
• Casual listening is primary use
• Simplicity is valued

Conclusion

Both speakers excel in their intended roles. The 707 S2 represents a serious investment in audio quality, requiring additional components but delivering reference-level performance. The R1280TS offers remarkable value, providing good sound quality in an accessible package.

For the budget-conscious or those seeking simplicity, the R1280TS is an excellent choice. However, if you're passionate about audio quality and willing to invest in a complete system, the 707 S2 delivers performance that justifies its premium pricing.

Remember: speaker choice is highly personal, and listening to both options in your intended space, if possible, is always recommended.

Bowers & Wilkins 707 S2 Bookshelf Speaker - Pair Deals and Prices

Edifier R1280TS Powered Bookshelf Speakers Deals and Prices