Choosing Between Premium and Budget Bookshelf Speakers: An In-Depth Comparison

Understanding Modern Bookshelf Speakers

When it comes to home audio, bookshelf speakers remain a popular choice for their versatility and space-efficient design. Today we're comparing two very different approaches: the premium Bowers & Wilkins 707 S2 ($959) and the budget-friendly Edifier R1280T ($84). Despite their vast price difference, both aim to deliver quality sound in compact packages.

Bookshelf speakers have evolved significantly over the past decade. The key advancement has been in driver materials and cabinet design, with companies like B&W developing proprietary technologies that push sound quality forward. Meanwhile, brands like Edifier have made quality audio more accessible through efficient manufacturing and integrated amplification.

A Tale of Two Design Philosophies

The B&W 707 S2, released in 2017, represents the high-end passive speaker approach. These speakers require a separate amplifier but offer exceptional audio performance through advanced technologies like their Continuum cone (which replaced B&W's famous yellow Kevlar) and Carbon Dome tweeter. The Continuum material reduces unwanted resonances that can color the sound, resulting in clearer, more accurate audio reproduction.

In contrast, the Edifier R1280T, introduced around 2020, takes the powered speaker route. By building amplification directly into the speaker, Edifier eliminates the need for additional equipment. This modern approach simplifies setup while keeping costs down, though it does limit future upgrade paths.

Performance Deep Dive

Sound Quality and Character

The 707 S2's sound signature is remarkably refined, with its Carbon Dome tweeter handling frequencies up to 47kHz - well beyond human hearing but contributing to a sense of "air" and spaciousness in the music. The speaker's Continuum cone controls break-up modes (unwanted vibrations that distort sound) far better than traditional materials, resulting in clearer midrange frequencies where vocals and most instruments live.

The R1280T takes a more consumer-friendly approach, with a slightly bass-forward sound that many listeners find enjoyable. Its silk dome tweeter and paper cone woofer are traditional materials that perform well but lack the technical sophistication of B&W's proprietary drivers. While it can't match the 707 S2's clarity and detail, it produces a warm, pleasant sound that works well for casual listening.

Power and Amplification

Here's where the designs diverge significantly. The 707 S2 requires an external amplifier, ideally providing 30-100 watts per channel into 8 ohms. Its relatively low 84dB sensitivity means it needs more power to reach higher volumes. However, this separation of components allows users to choose amplification that matches their preferences and upgrade over time.

The R1280T's built-in 21-watt-per-channel amplifier is perfectly matched to its drivers but limits maximum volume and dynamic range. While sufficient for near-field listening (like at a desk) or small rooms, it may struggle to fill larger spaces with sound.

Room Integration and Placement

B&W's 707 S2 features a rear-firing Flowport that helps extend bass response but requires careful placement away from walls. The speaker's high-end capabilities mean it will reveal both the strengths and weaknesses of your room acoustics. However, when properly set up, it creates a remarkably precise soundstage where you can pinpoint the location of each instrument.

The R1280T is more forgiving of placement, though its rear bass port still benefits from some space behind it. Its built-in tone controls allow for basic adjustment to room acoustics, something the passive 707 S2 can't do without external equipment.

Value and Long-Term Considerations

The B&W 707 S2 represents a significant investment, especially when factoring in appropriate amplification. However, its superior build quality and performance ceiling mean it could serve as the foundation of a high-end system for many years. The speakers are also bi-wire capable, allowing for future upgrades to amplification.

The Edifier R1280T provides remarkable value for its price point. While it won't scale up like the 707 S2, it delivers enjoyable sound quality and includes everything needed to start listening immediately. Its dual RCA inputs also provide useful flexibility for connecting multiple sources.

Home Theater Applications

For home theater use, the 707 S2's superior dynamics and detail retrieval make it an excellent choice for front left/right channels. Its ability to handle complex sound mixes while maintaining clarity helps create an immersive movie experience. However, you'll need an AV receiver capable of driving these speakers effectively.

The R1280T can work in a simple TV setup through its analog inputs, but it's not ideal for modern home theater use due to its limited inputs and power. It's better suited for stereo music listening or as a TV sound upgrade in smaller rooms.

Making the Choice

Choose the 707 S2 if you're serious about audio quality and prepared to invest in a proper amplifier and source components. These speakers will reveal the nuances in well-recorded music and can serve as the foundation for a high-end system that will provide enjoyment for many years.

The R1280T makes more sense if you want good sound without complexity or high costs. It's particularly well-suited for desktop setups, small rooms, or as a significant upgrade from computer speakers. Its plug-and-play nature and included remote control make it exceptionally user-friendly.

Remember that the 707 S2's price tag doesn't include necessary amplification, while the R1280T is a complete solution. Consider your room size, listening preferences, and overall budget when making your decision.

The speaker market continues to evolve, with both passive and powered designs improving through new technologies and materials. Whether you choose the premium performance of the 707 S2 or the practical value of the R1280T, both represent solid choices within their respective categories.

Bowers & Wilkins 707 S2 Bookshelf Speaker - Pair Deals and Prices

Edifier R1280T Powered Bookshelf Speakers - Pair Deals and Prices