Ultra Short Throw Laser Projectors: BenQ vs Leica - A Deep Dive Comparison

When it comes to creating a premium home theater experience, BenQ's V5010i and Leica's Cine 1 represent two distinct approaches to high-end projection technology. Both released within the past year, these projectors showcase how far ultra short throw (UST) technology has come.

Understanding the Technology

Ultra short throw projectors represent a significant advance in home theater tech. Unlike traditional projectors that need to sit far from the screen, UST projectors can create massive images from just inches away. This is achieved through sophisticated lens systems and laser light sources that provide both better color accuracy and longer lifespans than traditional lamp-based projectors.

The BenQ V5010i launched in early 2024, bringing several refinements to the UST category. Its RGB laser system produces 2500 ANSI lumens (a standard measure of brightness) and covers an impressive 95% of the professional BT.2020 color space. For context, that's significantly more colors than your typical TV can display.

Leica's entry into the projector market with the Cine 1 in late 2023 brought their legendary lens expertise to home theater. The Cine 1 pushes brightness higher to 3000 ANSI lumens and achieves 100% of the BT.2020 color space, though these specs only tell part of the story.

Image Quality Deep Dive

Color Performance

Both projectors excel at color reproduction, but take different approaches. The BenQ uses advanced color temperature tuning with 11 levels of white balance control, allowing for precise adjustment of mid-tones - the colors we're most sensitive to. This helps ensure natural skin tones and realistic landscapes.

Leica's approach leverages their century-plus of optical expertise. Their Summicron lens system, featuring four precisely manufactured aspherical elements, delivers noticeably better edge-to-edge sharpness and reduced color fringing (where you might see slight rainbow effects around high-contrast edges).

Brightness and Contrast

While the Leica boasts higher peak brightness, the BenQ's 2,500,000:1 dynamic contrast ratio helps it deliver better performance in dark scenes. This is particularly noticeable when watching movies with lots of shadow detail, like space films or noir classics.

Both projectors support HDR (High Dynamic Range) content, with the BenQ offering HDR10+ support for scene-by-scene optimization. The Leica counters with superior highlight detail thanks to its higher brightness.

Installation and Setup

The BenQ V5010i shines when it comes to ease of setup. Its Auto Screen Fit feature automatically adjusts the image to match your screen, while 8-point corner adjustment lets you fine-tune the geometry if needed. This is particularly valuable if you can't place the projector in an absolutely perfect position.

The Leica takes a more traditional approach, requiring manual adjustment but potentially offering more precise control for those willing to take the time. Both projectors need about 14-15 inches of distance from the wall to create a 120-inch image.

Smart Features and Connectivity

BenQ's implementation of Google-certified Android TV provides a more comprehensive smart platform, with native support for major streaming services and voice control. Three HDMI 2.0b ports support 4K@120Hz input, making it more future-proof for gaming and high-frame-rate content.

The Leica Cine 1 focuses more on core performance than smart features, though it does include basic streaming capabilities. Its HDMI 2.1 ports provide plenty of bandwidth for current and future sources.

Gaming Performance

For gamers, the BenQ's Auto Low Latency Mode (ALLM) automatically optimizes settings for reduced input lag when gaming sources are detected. While exact input lag numbers aren't available for the Leica, its focus on image processing suggests it may not be as responsive for gaming.

Audio Capabilities

The BenQ includes a surprisingly capable 40W audio system with dedicated tweeters and woofers. While serious home theater setups will still want external speakers, it's perfectly serviceable for casual viewing. Both projectors support eARC for passing high-quality audio to external sound systems.

Long-term Considerations

Both projectors use laser light sources rated for 20,000+ hours of use, meaning they should last over a decade with typical use. The Leica's superior lens system may maintain better image quality over time, though both represent significant improvements over traditional lamp-based projectors.

Value Analysis

At their respective price points, these projectors target different segments of the market. The BenQ delivers exceptional value with its combination of performance and features. The Leica commands a premium price but delivers reference-quality image performance that may justify the cost for serious enthusiasts.

How to Decide

Choose the BenQ V5010i if:

• You want the best balance of features and value
• Gaming performance is important
• You appreciate automated setup features
• Smart TV functionality is a priority

Choose the Leica Cine 1 if:

• Absolute image quality is your priority
• You have a brighter viewing environment
• You're willing to spend time on manual optimization
• Budget is secondary to performance

Final Thoughts

The BenQ V5010i represents the sweet spot for most users, combining excellent performance with valuable quality-of-life features. The Leica Cine 1 sets a new standard for image quality in UST projectors, though at a premium price that will limit its appeal to serious enthusiasts.

Both projectors show how far home theater technology has advanced, offering cinema-quality experiences in packages that can work in many living spaces. Your choice ultimately depends on your priorities between absolute performance and overall value.

BenQ V5010i 4K Laser Projector Deals and Prices

Leica Cine 1 120" 4K Ultra Short Throw Laser Projector Deals and Prices