Ultra Short Throw 4K Laser Projector Comparison: BenQ vs Hisense

If you're looking to build a serious home theater setup in 2024, ultra short throw (UST) laser projectors represent one of the most exciting developments in recent years. Today we're comparing two leading options: the BenQ V5010i ($3,499) and the Hisense PX3-PRO ($3,497).

The Evolution of UST Projectors

UST projectors have transformed home theater possibilities by projecting huge images from just inches away from your wall. Unlike traditional projectors that need significant room depth, these units sit directly below your screen. Both of our contenders use advanced laser light sources instead of traditional bulbs, offering better color, instant on/off, and lifespans of 20,000+ hours.

Image Quality Deep Dive

The core of any projector comparison has to start with image quality. Both the BenQ V5010i and Hisense PX3-PRO deliver 4K resolution using pixel-shifting technology, which rapidly moves 1080p chips to create a 4K image. While not native 4K, the difference is barely noticeable in real-world use.

Brightness and Room Conditions

The Hisense takes the lead in raw brightness, outputting 3,000 ANSI lumens compared to the BenQ's 2,500. This 20% advantage makes a real difference in rooms with ambient light. ANSI lumens, unlike marketing lumens, represent standardized measurements you can trust.

The BenQ counters with superior contrast, sporting an impressive 2,500,000:1 ratio versus the Hisense's 3,000:1. This gives the BenQ noticeably better black levels and shadow detail in dark room viewing. However, this advantage diminishes significantly with any ambient light present.

Color Performance

Both projectors excel in color accuracy, using RGB laser light sources to exceed traditional lamp-based systems. The Hisense edges ahead with 110% BT.2020 coverage versus the BenQ's 95%. For context, BT.2020 is the widest color standard currently used, with most content mastered in the smaller DCI-P3 space that both projectors cover completely.

The BenQ offers superior out-of-box calibration, requiring minimal adjustment for accurate colors. The Hisense can match this accuracy but may need some tweaking of its more extensive calibration controls.

Gaming Capabilities

Modern projectors need to handle gaming, and there's a clear winner here. The Hisense PX3-PRO supports Auto Low Latency Mode (ALLM) and Variable Refresh Rate (VRR), key features for responsive gaming. It also includes HDMI 2.1 ports supporting higher bandwidth for 4K/120Hz gaming.

The BenQ includes basic ALLM support but lacks VRR and high-refresh-rate capabilities. Its input lag, while acceptable for casual gaming, can't match the Hisense's more gaming-focused design.

Smart Features and Connectivity

Streaming and Smart TV

The Hisense implements a full Google TV system with access to all major streaming services. This includes Netflix, Disney+, and Amazon Prime Video with full HDR support. The interface is smooth and familiar to Android users.

The BenQ uses a more basic Android TV implementation that, while functional, doesn't feel as polished. Some streaming apps may be limited or missing compared to the Hisense.

Physical Connections

Both projectors offer multiple HDMI ports, but the Hisense's HDMI 2.1 support provides more future-proofing. Both include eARC for passing high-quality audio to external receivers, essential for serious home theater setups.

Installation and Setup

UST projectors require careful placement for optimal image alignment. Both units include automatic geometric correction and focus features, but they work differently:

• The BenQ V5010i offers simpler auto-alignment but may require more manual tweaking
• The Hisense provides more comprehensive adjustment tools but has a steeper learning curve

The Hisense's shorter throw ratio (0.23:1 vs 0.25:1) means it can sit slightly closer to the wall for the same image size, which might matter in tight spaces.

Audio Performance

While external speakers or a sound bar are recommended for the best experience, both projectors include surprisingly capable built-in audio:

• Hisense: 50W Harman Kardon system with better bass response
• BenQ: 40W system with clearer dialogue but less low-end

Value Analysis

At virtually identical price points (~$3,500), the value proposition comes down to use case:

The Hisense PX3-PRO offers more features and better versatility:

• Superior gaming support
• Better smart TV implementation
• Higher brightness for mixed lighting conditions
• More extensive HDR format support including Dolby Vision

The BenQ V5010i excels in pure home theater performance:

• Better contrast for dark room viewing
• More accurate out-of-box picture
• Simpler operation
• Slightly better motion handling

How to Decide

Choose the BenQ if:

• You're building a dedicated home theater room
• Picture accuracy is your top priority
• You prefer simpler operation
• You mainly watch movies in dark conditions

Choose the Hisense if:

• Your room has varying light conditions
• Gaming is a priority
• You want the best smart TV features
• You need maximum brightness

Technical Improvements Since Release

Both projectors launched in early 2024, representing the latest in UST technology. Key improvements over previous generations include:

• Enhanced HDR processing
• Better geometric correction
• Improved smart features
• More gaming-friendly features

The Hisense particularly stands out for incorporating HDMI 2.1 and Dolby Vision support, features previously rare in the projector market.

For most users, the Hisense PX3-PRO represents the better all-around choice due to its versatility and feature set. However, dedicated home theater enthusiasts prioritizing pure image quality in controlled lighting might prefer the BenQ V5010i. Either way, both represent excellent examples of how far UST projection technology has come.

BenQ V5010i 4K Laser Projector Deals and Prices

Hisense PX3-PRO 4K Ultra Short Throw Projector Deals and Prices