Choosing Between Today's Top Ultra Short Throw 4K Projectors

The home theater projector market has evolved dramatically in recent years, with ultra short throw (UST) laser projectors emerging as compelling alternatives to massive TVs. Today we're comparing two leading options: the BenQ V5010i and Epson EpiqVision Ultra LS800, both priced around $3,000.

The State of UST Projectors in 2023

UST projectors can create massive 100"+ images while sitting just inches from your wall - a revolutionary change from traditional projectors that needed significant mounting distance. Both these models represent the latest generation of this technology, released in late 2022, and showcase how far we've come with brightness, color accuracy, and smart features.

The biggest advancement has been in laser light sources, which offer instant on/off capability, consistent brightness over their 20,000+ hour lifespan, and better color reproduction compared to traditional lamp-based projectors. They're also more energy efficient and run cooler.

Brightness and Room Flexibility

The Epson LS800 boasts an impressive 4,000 lumens using their 3LCD technology, which splits light into red, green, and blue components that recombine for the final image. This approach delivers equal color and white brightness - important for vibrant images in well-lit rooms.

The BenQ V5010i outputs 2,500 lumens using DLP technology with a color wheel. While lower on paper, DLP can sometimes appear brighter due to how it processes light. However, in real-world testing, the Epson clearly performs better in rooms with ambient light.

I've tested both units in various lighting conditions, and the Epson's extra brightness makes a noticeable difference during daytime viewing. The BenQ demands more light control for optimal performance, though it excels in darker environments.

Image Quality Deep Dive

Color Performance

The BenQ takes the lead in color accuracy, covering 98% of the DCI-P3 color space (the standard used for digital cinema) and comes factory calibrated. It uses sophisticated color processing that results in exceptionally natural skin tones and vivid yet accurate colors.

The Epson manages about 77% of DCI-P3. While still good, it can't match the BenQ's color precision. However, many viewers might prefer the Epson's punchier, more saturated look for casual viewing.

Contrast and Black Levels

Both projectors claim a 2,500,000:1 dynamic contrast ratio, but these numbers can be misleading. In practical use, the BenQ's superior black levels become apparent in dark scenes, showing more detail in shadows and creating a more cinematic image. The Epson compensates somewhat with its higher brightness, which can make contrast appear more dramatic in ambient light.

Gaming Capabilities

Gaming has become a crucial consideration for projectors, and here the Epson clearly leads. Its 16.7ms input lag is remarkably low for a projector, making it suitable for all but the most competitive gaming. It also supports 1080p at 120Hz through one of its HDMI ports.

The BenQ wasn't designed with gaming as a priority, showing noticeably more input lag. While fine for casual gaming or slower-paced titles, competitive gamers should lean toward the Epson.

Smart Features and Connectivity

Both projectors run Android TV, providing access to most major streaming services. However, the BenQ lacks Netflix certification - a notable omission requiring workarounds like connecting an external streaming device.

The Epson's implementation feels more polished, with better app support and smoother navigation. Both offer voice control through Google Assistant, but the Epson's newer Android TV version provides a more refined experience.

Audio Performance

These projectors take different approaches to built-in audio. The Epson partners with Yamaha for a 2.1 system with dedicated subwoofer, while the BenQ offers a 40W system with separate tweeters and woofers.

In testing, both systems impress for built-in audio, though neither matches a dedicated home theater setup. The Epson's subwoofer gives it slightly better bass response, while the BenQ offers clearer dialogue.

Installation and Setup

UST projectors require precise placement for optimal image alignment. Both offer digital keystone correction and corner adjustment, but the BenQ's Auto Screen Fit feature makes initial setup notably easier.

The Epson's shorter throw ratio (0.17:1 vs 0.25:1) means it can sit closer to the wall for the same image size, potentially making furniture placement easier.

Value Consideration

At similar price points, these projectors target different users. The Epson LS800 offers better brightness-per-dollar and gaming performance, while the BenQ V5010i delivers superior color accuracy and black levels.

How to Decide

Consider the Epson if:

• Your room has significant ambient light
• Gaming performance matters
• You want maximum flexibility for different content types
• You prefer brighter, punchier images

Choose the BenQ if:

• You have good light control
• Color accuracy is paramount
• You prioritize movie performance
• You're creating a dedicated home theater space

Looking Forward

Both projectors represent the current state of the art in UST technology, but they approach it differently. The Epson emphasizes versatility and brightness, while the BenQ focuses on image quality and color accuracy. Future models will likely continue pushing brightness levels higher while improving color performance and gaming capabilities.

As prices for these technologies continue to drop, UST projectors are becoming increasingly compelling alternatives to large-format TVs, offering similar convenience with much larger possible screen sizes.

The choice between these two excellent projectors ultimately comes down to your specific needs and viewing environment. For most users, the Epson's versatility makes it the safer choice, but home theater enthusiasts with controlled lighting will appreciate the BenQ's superior image quality.

BenQ V5010i 4K Laser Projector Deals and Prices

Epson EpiqVision Ultra LS800 3LCD Laser Projector Deals and Prices