Smart video doorbells have transformed from simple notification devices to sophisticated home security hubs. In 2023, we're seeing incredible advances in video quality, AI detection, and smart home integration. Let's dive into two leading contenders: the Arlo Video Doorbell 2nd Generation and the Ring Battery Doorbell.
Today's smart doorbells combine high-definition cameras, two-way audio, motion detection, and cloud connectivity. These features help you monitor your entrance, communicate with visitors, and protect deliveries - whether you're home or away. The latest models incorporate AI for better detection and HDR (High Dynamic Range) imaging for clearer video in challenging lighting conditions.
The Arlo Video Doorbell 2nd Generation offers two resolution options: a 1080p model at $79.99 and a 2K (1536 x 1536 pixels) version at $129.99. Its 180-degree field of view is particularly impressive, allowing you to see visitors from head to toe and packages left at your doorstep. The square aspect ratio (1:1) proves especially useful for porch coverage.
The Ring Battery Doorbell features 1536p resolution with a 150-degree horizontal and vertical field of view. While slightly narrower than Arlo's view, Ring's HDR processing often produces better results in challenging lighting situations, like bright sunlight or deep shadows.
Both doorbells include night vision, but Ring's color night vision technology provides more natural-looking footage after dark. This can be crucial for accurately describing suspicious activities to authorities.
Arlo's dual power options offer welcome flexibility. You can hardwire it to existing doorbell wiring or use battery power. The battery version includes new technology that extends life between charges, though exact duration claims aren't specified.
Ring's battery-only approach might seem limiting, but their quick-release mount is genuinely clever. You can pop out the battery for charging without removing the entire doorbell. The USB-C charging is convenient, though you'll want a spare battery ($29.99) if you're concerned about downtime during charging.
Both doorbells have evolved significantly in their AI capabilities since release. Arlo's system excels at distinguishing between people, animals, vehicles, and packages. The integrated siren (a unique feature) can be triggered automatically or manually through the app - particularly useful for deterring package thieves.
Ring's package detection focuses specifically on delivery monitoring, with customizable zones that trigger notifications when packages arrive. While more limited than Arlo's broader detection categories, it works reliably for its intended purpose.
Ring's tight integration with Alexa makes it the clear choice for Amazon ecosystem users. Voice commands like "Alexa, show me the front door" work seamlessly with Echo devices. However, Ring requires a subscription (starting at $3.99/month) to access recorded video and advanced features.
Arlo also requires a subscription (Arlo Secure, starting at $4.99/month) for cloud recording and advanced detection. However, it offers broader smart home compatibility, working with Alexa, Google Assistant, and Apple HomeKit - though HomeKit support varies by model.
In practical testing, both doorbells handle their core functions well, but with different strengths:
Since their releases in late 2023, both companies have pushed regular firmware updates. Arlo has improved its AI detection accuracy and added new quick-response messages. Ring has enhanced its package detection algorithms and expanded its custom alert options.
The Arlo Video Doorbell 2nd Generation offers more features at its price points:
The Ring Battery Doorbell at $99.99 hits a sweet spot for Alexa users who prioritize:
Choose Arlo if you:
Choose Ring if you:
Both companies continue to innovate in the smart doorbell space. Arlo's focus on AI and higher resolution suggests they're targeting the premium market, while Ring's emphasis on user-friendly features and ecosystem integration shows a focus on mainstream adoption.
The smart doorbell category continues to evolve, with future improvements likely in AI accuracy, battery life, and video quality. Both these models represent solid choices for current buyers, with your specific needs and existing smart home setup being the key deciding factors.
Remember to consider your long-term plans - if you're building out a smart home system, ecosystem compatibility might outweigh individual feature advantages. Both companies have proven track records for software updates and ongoing support, so either choice should serve well for years to come.
| Arlo Video Doorbell 2nd Generation | Ring Battery Doorbell |
|---|---|
| Resolution - Determines image clarity and detail recognition | |
| 1080p ($79.99) or 2K 1536x1536 ($129.99) options | 1536p HD resolution |
| Field of View - Affects how much of your entryway is visible | |
| 180° diagonal view (better package visibility) | 150° horizontal x 150° vertical view |
| Power Options - Impacts installation flexibility and maintenance | |
| Battery or hardwired installation | Battery-only with quick-release mount |
| Night Vision - Critical for evening security | |
| Standard infrared night vision | Color night vision with better detail |
| Smart Home Integration - Affects ecosystem compatibility | |
| Works with Alexa, Google Assistant, Apple HomeKit | Alexa-only integration |
| Additional Security Features - Enhanced protection options | |
| Built-in siren, advanced AI detection for people/animals/vehicles | Package alerts, customizable motion zones |
| Subscription Costs - Ongoing expenses for full features | |
| Arlo Secure from $4.99/month | Ring Protect from $3.99/month |
| Motion Detection Range - Affects alert accuracy | |
| Up to 3m (2K version), 5m (wired version) | Customizable zones up to 9m |
| Special Features - Unique capabilities | |
| VoIP call notifications, square aspect ratio for better coverage | Quick-release battery, color night vision, head-to-toe view |
| Price Point - Total investment consideration | |
| $79.99 (1080p) or $129.99 (2K) | $99.99 |
The Arlo Video Doorbell 2nd Generation offers better overall features with a 180° view and dual power options, while the Ring Battery Doorbell excels in Alexa integration and battery management. Arlo is better for premium features, Ring for ease of use.
The Arlo Video Doorbell 2nd Generation costs $79.99 for 1080p or $129.99 for 2K resolution. The Ring Battery Doorbell is priced at $99.99, making it a mid-range option.
The Ring Battery Doorbell features superior color night vision, while the Arlo Video Doorbell 2nd Generation uses standard infrared night vision. Ring's color night vision provides more detail in low-light conditions.
Both doorbells can display video feeds on your home theater setup. The Ring Battery Doorbell works through Fire TV devices, while Arlo supports multiple platforms including Chromecast and Apple TV.
The 2K version of the Arlo Video Doorbell 2nd Generation offers the highest resolution at 1536x1536 pixels, while the Ring Battery Doorbell provides 1536p HD resolution. Both deliver clear, detailed images.
The Ring Battery Doorbell is simpler to install with its battery-only design and quick-release mount. The Arlo Video Doorbell 2nd Generation offers more flexibility but may require more setup time.
Yes, both doorbells can stream to TVs. The Ring Battery Doorbell works best with Fire TV devices, while Arlo supports more streaming options including Apple TV, Chromecast, and Fire TV.
The Arlo Video Doorbell 2nd Generation offers more advanced AI detection for people, animals, and vehicles. The Ring Battery Doorbell focuses on package detection and customizable motion zones.
The Ring Battery Doorbell features a quick-release battery system making changes easier. The Arlo Video Doorbell 2nd Generation uses new battery technology for extended life, though exact durations vary by usage.
The Arlo Video Doorbell 2nd Generation works with Alexa, Google Assistant, and Apple HomeKit. The Ring Battery Doorbell only works with Alexa but offers deeper integration within the Amazon ecosystem.
While the Ring Battery Doorbell has specific package detection features, the Arlo Video Doorbell 2nd Generation offers better overall coverage with its wider angle and AI detection system.
We've done our best to create useful and informative comparisons to help you decide what product to buy. Our research uses advanced automated methods to create this comparison and perfection is not possible - please contact us for corrections or questions. These are the sites we've researched in the creation of this article: security.org - arlo.com - bestbuy.com - androidcentral.com - arlo.com - community.arlo.com - youtube.com - community.arlo.com - community.arlo.com - arlo.com - t-mobile.com - youtube.com - pcrichard.com - marketplace.ladwp.com - ae-en.ring.com - batteries4pro.com - de-de.ring.com - de-de.ring.com - careyscommunications.com
