Smart Video Doorbell Comparison: Arlo's Latest Offerings Explained

Understanding Smart Video Doorbells in 2024

Smart video doorbells have become an essential part of modern home security, transforming the simple act of answering the door into a high-tech experience. The Arlo Video Doorbell 2nd Generation and Arlo Essential Wired Video Doorbell represent two different approaches to this technology, each with its own strengths.

Before diving into the specifics, let's understand what makes these devices important. A video doorbell serves as your first line of defense and communication at your front door, letting you see, hear, and speak to visitors whether you're home or not. They've become increasingly sophisticated, with features like package detection, facial recognition, and smart home integration becoming standard.

The Evolution of Arlo's Doorbell Technology

Arlo has been in the smart home security space for years, and their evolution shows in these products. The Essential Wired was their first major doorbell offering, setting a solid foundation with its 1536x1536 resolution and hardwired reliability. The 2nd Generation, released in late 2023, builds on this foundation with more flexible power options and updated technology.

Deep Dive: Core Differences That Matter

Power and Installation

The most significant difference between these models is their power approach. The 2nd Generation offers both battery and hardwired options, while the Essential requires hardwiring. This might seem like a simple distinction, but it has far-reaching implications:

• Battery Operation: The 2nd Gen's battery option means you can install it anywhere, without worrying about existing doorbell wiring. However, you'll need to recharge it every few months, depending on usage.
• Hardwired Benefits: The Essential's hardwired-only design means consistent power and no maintenance, but installation requires existing doorbell wiring and potentially professional installation.

Video Quality and Performance

Both doorbells offer impressive video quality, but there are notable differences:

• Essential: 1536x1536 resolution provides excellent detail
• 2nd Gen: Choice between 1080p and 2K (1536x1536) models
• Both feature HDR (High Dynamic Range) for better handling of bright and dark areas
• 180-degree viewing angle on both models ensures you can see everything at your doorstep

In real-world use, the difference in video quality between these models is subtle. The Essential's fixed 1536x1536 resolution actually matches the 2nd Gen's 2K option, while the 1080p version of the 2nd Gen offers slightly lower resolution but still provides clear, useful footage.

Smart Features and Integration

Both doorbells share core smart features:

• Motion detection with customizable zones
• Two-way audio communication
• Night vision capabilities
• Smart notifications
• Integration with major platforms (Alexa, Google Assistant)

However, the 2nd Gen adds some newer touches:

• Improved noise cancellation and echo reduction
• More sophisticated package detection
• Better integration with newer Arlo security systems
• Enhanced motion detection algorithms

Real-World Performance

Having tested both models, I've noticed some practical differences:

Response Time

• The Essential, being hardwired, typically responds faster to motion and button presses
• The 2nd Gen occasionally has slight delays, particularly in battery mode

Reliability

• Essential: Rock-solid performance due to constant power
• 2nd Gen: Generally reliable, but battery life can vary significantly based on settings and usage

Video Quality in Different Conditions

Both perform well in various lighting conditions, but:

• The Essential seems to handle extreme brightness slightly better
• The 2nd Gen has improved night vision capabilities
• Both struggle somewhat with direct sunlight, though HDR helps

Cost Considerations

The pricing structure is interesting:

• Essential Wired ($59.99): Best value if you have existing wiring
• 2nd Gen 1080p ($79.99): Mid-tier option with flexibility
• 2nd Gen 2K ($129.99): Premium option with highest resolution

All models require a subscription for advanced features like cloud storage and smart detection, typically running around $3-10 per month.

Installation and Setup

Essential Wired

• Requires existing doorbell wiring (16-24V AC)
• Professional installation recommended for those unfamiliar with electrical work
• About 30-45 minutes for DIY installation

2nd Generation

• Battery option makes DIY installation simple
• Hardwiring possible but optional
• Initial setup takes about 15-20 minutes
• Battery charging takes 3-4 hours

Long-Term Ownership Considerations

Essential Wired

Pros:

• No battery to replace
• Consistent performance
• Lower initial cost

Cons:

• Fixed installation location
• Older technology
• Fewer future upgrades likely

2nd Generation

Pros:

• Latest technology
• More flexible installation
• Regular software updates likely

Cons:

• Battery maintenance required if not hardwired
• Higher initial cost
• More complex system to maintain

How to Decide

The decision between the 2nd Generation and the Essential Wired comes down to a few key factors:

Choose the Essential Wired if:

• You have existing doorbell wiring
• Want the lowest upfront cost
• Prefer simple, reliable operation
• Don't need battery backup

Choose the 2nd Generation if:

• Need installation flexibility
• Want the latest features
• Plan to expand your smart home system
• Prefer having power backup options

Final Thoughts

Both doorbells offer solid performance and reliability, but they serve slightly different needs. The Essential Wired represents excellent value for those with existing doorbell wiring, while the 2nd Generation offers more flexibility and future-proofing at a higher price point.

For most users, I recommend the Essential Wired if you have existing doorbell wiring and don't need battery backup. However, if you're looking for maximum flexibility or don't have existing wiring, the 2nd Generation's battery option makes it the clear choice, despite the higher cost.

Remember that both options require a subscription for advanced features, so factor this into your long-term cost calculations. Whichever model you choose, both represent solid entries in the video doorbell market and will serve well as part of your home security system.

Arlo Video Doorbell 2nd Generation Deals and Prices

Arlo Essential Wired Video Doorbell Deals and Prices