Smart Home Entry Security in 2024: Comparing Video Doorbells and Smart Locks

When it comes to protecting your home's main entrance, two popular smart home approaches have emerged: dedicated video doorbells and integrated smart locks with cameras. Let's dive deep into comparing the Arlo Video Doorbell 2nd Generation ($79.99) and the Anker eufy Video Smart Lock S330 ($349.99) to help you make an informed decision about securing your entryway.

Understanding Modern Entry Security

The way we monitor and control access to our homes has evolved dramatically in the past few years. Traditional peepholes and basic deadbolts have given way to sophisticated digital solutions that let us see, hear, and interact with visitors whether we're home or not. But choosing between a dedicated video doorbell and an integrated smart lock system requires understanding some key differences.

The Evolution of Smart Entry Devices

The Arlo Video Doorbell 2nd Generation, released in 2023, represents the latest iteration of the dedicated video doorbell concept. It builds on the first generation by improving video quality to 2K resolution and enhancing the battery life with newer technology. The focus here is purely on monitoring and communication.

In contrast, the eufy Smart Lock S330 takes a more comprehensive approach by combining multiple functions into one device. This integration of a smart lock with high-quality video capabilities represents a newer trend in home security, offering both access control and monitoring in a single unit.

Core Features and Performance

Video Quality and Monitoring

Both devices offer 2K resolution, but they implement it differently. The Arlo provides a 180-degree field of view, which is ideal for seeing your entire porch area, including packages left on the ground. It uses HDR (High Dynamic Range) technology to balance bright and dark areas, particularly useful when your porch is partially in shadow.

The eufy S330's camera is optimized for a more focused view of the immediate door area. While its field of view is narrower, it excels at capturing detailed images of people actually using the lock, which is its primary purpose. The dual motion sensors (radar and PIR) provide more accurate detection with 95% fewer false alarms compared to single-sensor systems.

Smart Features and AI

Both devices offer AI-powered detection features, but with different emphases:

Arlo:

• Person, package, and animal detection
• Custom activity zones
• Pre-recorded quick responses
• These features require a subscription

eufy:

• Fingerprint recognition (0.3-second response)
• Dual motion detection
• Local storage without subscription
• Built-in AI for improved recognition

Installation and Setup

The Arlo doorbell installation is straightforward - it essentially replaces your existing doorbell with minimal tools required. It can work with your existing doorbell wiring or run on battery power, making it flexible for various situations.

The eufy S330 requires more involved installation since you're replacing your entire door lock mechanism. While it's designed to fit standard US and Canadian door preparations, you'll need to be comfortable with door hardware installation or hire a professional.

Real-World Performance

I've had the opportunity to test both devices, and each shines in different situations. The Arlo excels at what video doorbells do best - providing a clear view of visitors and deliveries. The two-way audio is clear and the pre-recorded messages are particularly useful when you're busy but need to acknowledge a visitor.

The eufy S330 truly stands out in its multi-functional approach. The fingerprint reader is impressively fast and reliable, while the video quality matches what you'd expect from a dedicated doorbell camera. The local storage option through the included Chime is a significant advantage for those concerned about privacy or subscription costs.

Value Consideration

The price difference between these devices is substantial, but it's important to consider what you're getting:

Arlo Video Doorbell at $79.99:

• Focused solution for visitor monitoring
• Requires subscription for advanced features
• Lower initial investment
• Simple installation

eufy Smart Lock S330 at $349.99:

• Complete entry security solution
• No subscription required
• Multiple access methods
• More complex installation
• Built-in backup battery

Integration and Ecosystem

Both devices work with major smart home platforms, though with some differences:

Arlo:

• Works with Amazon Alexa
• Limited Google Assistant support
• No Apple HomeKit support
• Requires Arlo hub for some features

eufy:

• Works with Amazon Alexa and Google Assistant
• No Apple HomeKit support
• Standalone operation possible
• Local storage through included Chime

Specific Use Cases

For Renters

The Arlo is clearly the better choice for renters, as it doesn't require modifying the door lock and can be easily removed when moving. The battery-powered option means no wiring is necessary.

For Homeowners

The eufy S330 makes more sense for homeowners who want to invest in a comprehensive entry solution. The combination of secure access control and monitoring provides more value over time, especially considering the lack of subscription fees.

For Multi-Family Homes

The eufy's multiple access methods (fingerprint, keypad, app, key) make it ideal for families or homes with frequent guests. You can assign different access types to different users and track usage through the app.

How to Make Your Decision

Consider these key factors when choosing between the Arlo Video Doorbell and eufy Smart Lock S330:

1. Primary Need
   • Choose Arlo if you primarily want to monitor visitors and deliveries
2. Choose eufy if you want both access control and monitoring
3. Budget Considerations
   • Initial cost vs. long-term subscription fees
4. Installation costs (professional installation may be needed for eufy)
5. Installation Preferences
   • Consider your comfort level with hardware installation
6. Think about whether you can modify your door (renters vs. owners)
7. Usage Patterns
   • How many people need access?
8. How important is remote access control?
9. Do you frequently have deliveries or visitors?

Looking Forward

Both devices represent different approaches to home entry security, and both do their primary jobs well. The Arlo offers a focused, cost-effective solution for monitoring, while the eufy provides a more comprehensive but expensive approach to entry security.

As these technologies continue to evolve, we'll likely see more integration between different security devices and potentially lower prices for integrated solutions like the eufy. For now, your choice should depend primarily on whether you need the access control features or if monitoring alone suffices for your situation.

Arlo Video Doorbell 2nd Generation Deals and Prices

Anker eufy Video Smart Lock S330 Door Lock Deals and Prices