Smart Video Doorbell Showdown: Next-Gen Doorbell Security for 2024

In an era where package theft and porch security are major concerns, video doorbells have evolved from novelty gadgets into essential home security tools. Today, we're comparing two popular options: the $200 Arlo Essential Wired Video Doorbell and the $179.99 Google Nest Doorbell Battery, both of which launched in 2021 but have received significant software updates since.

The Evolution of Smart Doorbells

Video doorbells have come a long way from simple cameras with buttons. Modern devices now incorporate artificial intelligence (AI), high-definition video, and sophisticated motion detection. These advancements help homeowners monitor deliveries, screen visitors, and maintain security with unprecedented convenience.

Installation and Power: A Tale of Two Approaches

The Arlo Essential Wired requires traditional doorbell wiring (16-24V AC), which might seem limiting but offers distinct advantages. Since it's always powered, you'll never miss an event due to a dead battery, and video quality remains consistently high. Installation typically takes about 30 minutes if you're replacing an existing doorbell, though you might want to consult an electrician if you're starting from scratch.

In contrast, the Google Nest Battery offers remarkable flexibility. You can hardwire it like the Arlo or use it completely wire-free. The battery typically lasts 2-6 months, depending on usage and settings. While this flexibility is convenient, there's a trade-off: the device occasionally needs a few seconds to "wake up" from its power-saving mode, potentially missing the first moment of activity.

Video Quality: The Details Matter

Here's where the technical differences become apparent. The Arlo delivers 1536x1536 resolution in a square format, while the Nest outputs 960x1280 in a portrait orientation. In practical terms, the Arlo's higher resolution means you can more easily identify faces and read package labels, especially when zooming in.

The field of view also differs significantly:

• Arlo: 180° diagonal view
• Nest: 145° diagonal view

This 35-degree difference might not sound huge, but it means the Arlo can show you packages left right against your door and capture full-height visitors, while the Nest might miss these edge cases.

Both devices support HDR (High Dynamic Range) imaging, which helps balance bright backgrounds with shadowed porches. However, the Arlo's higher native resolution gives it an edge in challenging lighting conditions.

Smart Features and AI Capabilities

While both doorbells offer smart features, their approaches differ significantly. The Nest leads in AI detection, using advanced algorithms to distinguish between:

• People
• Packages
• Vehicles
• Animals

This granular detection means fewer false alerts and more relevant notifications. The Nest can even recognize familiar faces if you subscribe to Nest Aware.

The Arlo Essential takes a more straightforward approach to motion detection but includes some unique features:

• Built-in siren for deterrence
• Direct-to-mobile video calls
• Quick reply messages
• Package detection

Both devices support two-way audio, but the Arlo's full-duplex system (allowing both parties to speak simultaneously) provides a more natural conversation experience.

Subscription Services and Costs

Understanding the subscription models is crucial for long-term value:

Nest:

• Free: 3 hours of event video history
• Nest Aware ($6/month): 30 days of event history
• Nest Aware Plus ($12/month): 60 days of event history + 10 days of 24/7 video

Arlo:

• Free: Live streaming only
• Arlo Secure ($12.99/month): 30 days of video history
• Arlo Secure Plus ($17.99/month): 30 days of video history + emergency response

Smart Home Integration

The Google Nest Doorbell naturally excels in Google Home integration, allowing seamless interaction with other Google devices. You can view the doorbell feed on Nest Hub displays or Chrome cast devices, and use Google Assistant for voice control.

The Arlo offers broader compatibility, working with:

• Amazon Alexa
• Google Assistant
• Apple HomeKit
• IFTTT

This flexibility makes it a better choice if you're not committed to a single smart home ecosystem.

Real-World Performance

After extensive testing, both devices perform well in their intended roles, but with different strengths:

Arlo Excel Points:

• Consistently faster response times
• Better video quality in all conditions
• Wider field of view
• More effective night vision
• Superior audio quality

Nest Strong Points:

• More intelligent notifications
• Better battery life when used wire-free
• More intuitive app interface
• Better free tier features
• More affordable initial cost

How to Make Your Decision

Choose the Arlo Essential Wired if:

• Video quality is your top priority
• You have existing doorbell wiring
• You want the widest possible view
• Security features like the built-in siren matter
• You're already using other Arlo cameras

Go with the Google Nest Battery if:

• You need installation flexibility
• Smart detection accuracy is important
• You want lower upfront costs
• You're invested in the Google Home ecosystem
• You prefer simpler subscription options

Looking Forward

Both companies regularly update their devices' software, adding features and improving performance. Since their 2021 launch, both have received multiple updates enhancing motion detection, notification systems, and smart home integration. The Arlo has gained better package detection and quick replies, while the Nest has improved its AI detection accuracy and added new alert types.

Conclusion

Both doorbells represent the current state of the art in their respective approaches. The Arlo emphasizes video quality and traditional security features, while the Nest focuses on AI capabilities and installation flexibility. Your choice should align with your specific needs and existing smart home setup.

For most users, the decision will come down to installation requirements and ecosystem preferences. If you're starting fresh and want flexibility, the Nest is an excellent choice. If you're replacing an existing doorbell and want the best possible video quality, the Arlo is worth the extra investment.

Arlo Essential Wired Video Doorbell Deals and Prices

Google Nest Doorbell Battery Video Doorbell Camera Deals and Prices