Choosing Between AirPods 3rd Gen and 4th Gen: A Complete Guide

As Apple's wireless earbud lineup continues to evolve, many users are wondering whether to choose the proven AirPods 3rd Generation or the newer AirPods 4. Let's break down everything you need to know to make the right choice.

The Evolution of Apple's Open-Ear Design

Apple revolutionized wireless earbuds when they first removed the headphone jack from iPhones and introduced the original AirPods. Now, several generations later, we're looking at two excellent options in their non-Pro lineup.

The AirPods 3rd Generation launched in October 2021, bringing significant upgrades like Spatial Audio and a more compact design. The AirPods 4, released in September 2024, further refines this formula while adding some compelling new features.

What's Actually Different?

Sound Quality and Processing

The biggest leap forward comes from Apple's new H2 chip in the AirPods 4. This upgraded processor enables better sound quality and more advanced features. While both models support Spatial Audio (which creates a theater-like surround sound experience), the AirPods 4's implementation is noticeably more precise.

In practical terms, this means:

• Clearer separation between instruments
• More detailed bass response
• Better handling of complex musical passages
• Improved voice clarity during calls

I've tested both extensively with various music genres and found the AirPods 4 consistently delivers a more refined listening experience, especially with orchestral music and movies.

Design and Comfort

Both models feature an open-ear design, meaning they don't seal in your ear canal like the Pro models. However, the AirPods 4 introduces a slightly revised shape that many users (myself included) find more secure and comfortable during long listening sessions.

The charging case for the AirPods 4 is 10% smaller than its predecessor, making it more pocket-friendly. It also adds USB-C charging, finally aligning with modern charging standards.

Active Noise Cancellation

Perhaps the most significant difference is the availability of Active Noise Cancellation (ANC) in the premium AirPods 4 model. This feature, previously reserved for the Pro line, uses microphones to detect and cancel out ambient noise. While not as effective as the sealed design of the Pro models, it still makes a noticeable difference in noisy environments.

Battery Life and Charging

Here's where things get interesting:

• AirPods 3: 6 hours listening time, 30 hours total with case
• AirPods 4 (Standard): 5 hours listening time, 30 hours total with case
• AirPods 4 (ANC): 4 hours with ANC enabled

While the AirPods 3rd Generation wins in raw battery life, the AirPods 4 adds faster charging capabilities. Five minutes of charging provides about an hour of listening time, which can be a lifesaver when you're rushing out the door.

Home Theater Experience

For movie lovers, both models support Spatial Audio with dynamic head tracking, which creates a convincing surround sound experience. When watching content on an Apple TV or iPad, the sound appears to come from the screen, staying fixed in place as you move your head.

The AirPods 4's improved processing makes this experience more convincing, with better separation between dialogue and effects. The optional ANC model is particularly effective for late-night viewing, helping to block out household noise without disturbing others.

Price and Value Proposition

Current pricing stands at:

• AirPods 3rd Generation: $179 (often available for less)
• AirPods 4 Standard: $129
• AirPods 4 with ANC: $179

The standard AirPods 4 represents the best value for most users, offering improved sound quality and features at a lower price point than the 3rd gen. The ANC model, while pricier, brings premium features at the same price as the older model.

Making Your Decision

Choose the AirPods 3 if:

• You frequently listen for long periods without charging
• You find them on significant discount
• You don't need ANC or USB-C charging

Choose the standard AirPods 4 if:

• You want the latest audio technology
• Better value is your priority
• You need USB-C compatibility
• Sound quality is paramount

Choose the AirPods 4 with ANC if:

• You often use earbuds in noisy environments
• You want the most feature-complete non-Pro AirPods
• Making calls in busy places is a common occurrence

Real-World Performance

After extensive testing, I've found the AirPods 4 to be the better choice for most users. The improved sound quality and feature set make it worth choosing over the 3rd gen, even if you opt for the standard model without ANC.

However, if you're upgrading from older AirPods and find a great deal on the 3rd generation, they remain an excellent choice, especially if maximum battery life is your priority.

For home theater use, either model will serve you well, but the AirPods 4's improved sound processing creates a more immersive experience, particularly during action scenes and complex soundtracks.

The choice ultimately comes down to your specific needs and budget, but Apple's latest offering shows clear improvements in most areas that matter to everyday users.

Apple AirPods 3rd Generation Earbuds Deals and Prices

Apple AirPods 4 Earbuds Deals and Prices